"Outlaw" mutations in quasispecies of SARS-CoV-2 inhibit replication

Philippe Colson,Jacques Fantini,Jeremy Delerce,Wahiba Bader,Anthony Levasseur,Pierre Pontarotti,Christian Devaux,Didier Raoult
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/22221751.2024.2368211
2024-06-26
Emerging Microbes & Infections
Abstract:The evolution of SARS-CoV-2, the agent of COVID-19, has been remarkable for its high mutation potential, leading to the appearance of variants. Some mutations have never appeared in the published genomes, which represent consensus, or bona fide genomes. Here we tested the hypothesis that mutations that did not appear in consensus genomes were, in fact, as frequent as the mutations that appeared during the various epidemic episodes, but were not expressed because lethal. To identify these mutations, we analysed the genomes of 90 nasopharyngeal samples and the quasispecies determined by next-generation sequencing. Mutations observed in the quasispecies and not in the consensus genomes were considered to be lethal, what we called "outlaw" mutations. Among these mutations, we analysed the 21 most frequent. Eight of these "outlaws" were in the RNA polymerase and we were able to use a structural biology model and molecular dynamics simulations to demonstrate the functional incapacity of these mutated RNA polymerases. Three other mutations affected the spike, a major protein involved in the pathogenesis of COVID-19. Overall, by analysing the SARS-CoV-2 quasispecies obtained during sequencing, this method made it possible to identify "outlaws," showing areas that could potentially become the target of treatments.
immunology,infectious diseases,microbiology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to identify mutations that exist in the SARS - CoV - 2 quasispecies but are never expressed in the consensus or "democratic" genome. These mutations are called "outlaw" mutations. The researchers hypothesize that these unexpressed mutations may be due to their lethality to the virus, that is, these mutations may lead to blocked virus replication or complete inability to replicate. By analyzing these "outlaw" mutations, the researchers hope to reveal areas that may be removed by natural selection during virus evolution, thus providing potential targets for the development of new antiviral treatment strategies. ### Main research content 1. **Background introduction**: - The high mutation potential of SARS - CoV - 2 has led to the emergence of multiple variants. - Some mutations have never appeared in the published genomes, which represent the consensus or real genomes. - The researchers hypothesize that these mutations that do not appear in the consensus genome are actually as frequent as those that appear in different epidemic stages, but are not expressed due to lethality. 2. **Methods**: - Analyzed the genomes of 90 nasopharyngeal samples and their quasispecies determined by next - generation sequencing (NGS). - Defined mutations observed in the quasispecies but not in the consensus genome as "outlaw" mutations. - Focused on analyzing 21 of the most common "outlaw" mutations, especially those located in the RNA - dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp). 3. **Results**: - Identified 21 of the most common "outlaw" mutations, of which 8 are located in RdRp, 3 are located in the spike protein (Spike), and the rest are distributed in other non - structural protein and nucleocapsid protein (Nucleocapsid) - coding genes. - Through structural biology models and molecular dynamics simulations, demonstrated the functional inactivation of RNA polymerase of these mutations. 4. **Discussion**: - These "outlaw" mutations appear in the same genes as the "hyperfertile" mutations (mutations that promote virus evolution), but are located at different nucleotide sites. - Nonsynonymous mutations may lead to the loss of RNA polymerase activity, thus affecting virus replication. - Synonymous mutations may affect translation kinetics by changing codon usage frequency, and then affect protein folding. - These observations are crucial for understanding the evolution of SARS - CoV - 2, revealing that some mutations promote the rapid development of the virus, while others lead to the failure of the virus. - The study also explored the role of intracellular APOBEC enzyme activity in generating "outlaw" mutations, and the possibility that these mutations may hybridize with microRNA or other coding or non - coding elements in the human genome, which may be a new mechanism of adaptive immunity. ### Conclusion This study, by analyzing the "outlaw" mutations in the SARS - CoV - 2 quasispecies, revealed the important role of these mutations in virus evolution. These mutations may not be expressed in the consensus genome due to their lethality, but their existence provides potential targets for the development of new antiviral treatment strategies.