Abstract:Virtual reality (VR) technology is commonly used in balance research due to its ability to simulate real world experiences under controlled experimental conditions. However, several studies reported considerable differences in balance behavior in real world environments as compared to virtual environments presented in a head mounted display. Most of these studies were conducted more than a decade ago, at a time when VR was still struggling with major technical limitations (delays, limited field-of-view, etc.). In the meantime, VR technology has progressed considerably, enhancing its capacity to induce the feeling of presence and behavioural realism. In this study, we addressed two questions: Has VR technology now reached a point where balance is similar in real and virtual environments? And does the integration of visual cues for balance depend on the subjective experience of presence? We used a state-of-the-art head mounted VR system and a custom-made balance platform to compare balance when viewing (1) a real-world environment, (2) a photo-realistic virtual copy of the real-world environment, (3) an abstract virtual environment consisting of only spheres and bars ('low presence' VR condition), and, as reference, (4) a condition with eyes closed. Body sway of ten participants was measured in three different support surface conditions: (A) quiet stance, (B) stance on a sway referenced surface, and (C) surface tilting following a pseudo-random sequence. A 2-level repeated measures ANOVA and PostHoc analyses revealed no significant differences in body sway between viewing the real world environment and the photo-realistic virtual copy. In contrast, body sway was increased in the 'low presence' abstract scene and further increased with eyes closed. Results were consistent across platform conditions. Our results support the hypothesis that state of the art VR reached a point of behavioural realism in which balance in photo-realistic VR is similar to balance in a real environment. Presence was lower in the abstract virtual condition as compared to the photo-realistic condition as measured by the IPQ presence questionnaire. Thus, our results indicate that spatial presence may be a moderating factor, but further research is required to confirm this notion. We conceive that virtual reality is a valid tool for balance research, but that the properties of the virtual environment affects results.

Sitting or Standing in VR: About Comfort, Conflicts, and Hazards

A review on ergonomics evaluations of virtual reality

How to Improve Your Virtual Experience -- Exploring the Obstacles of Mainstream VR

Virtual reality as a tool for balance research: Eyes open body sway is reproduced in photo-realistic, but not in abstract virtual scenes

Cybersickness and postural stability of first time VR users playing VR videogames

Comfort and Sickness while Virtually Aboard an Autonomous Telepresence Robot

Action-control mappings of interfaces in virtual reality: A study of embodied interaction

Eyes on teleporting: comparing locomotion techniques in Virtual Reality with respect to presence, sickness and spatial orientation

On Rotation Gains Within and Beyond Perceptual Limitations for Seated VR

To use or not to use viewpoint oscillations when walking in VR ? State of the art and perspectives

Postural instability in an immersive Virtual Reality adapts with repetition and includes directional and gender specific effects

Alterations in Physical Demands During Virtual/Augmented Reality-Based Tasks: A Systematic Review

Evolution of postural control assessment: From dynamic posturography to virtual reality

Leaning-Based Interfaces Improve Simultaneous Locomotion and Object Interaction in VR Compared to the Handheld Controller

Creating widely accessible spatial interfaces: mobile VR for managing persistent pain

A meta-analysis of the virtual reality problem: Unequal effects of virtual reality sickness across individual differences

Discussing Risks and Benefits in the Future of Hybrid Rehabilitation and Fitness in Mixed Reality

Augmenting Teleportation in Virtual Reality With Discrete Rotation Angles

Reaching interactions in virtual reality: the effect of movement direction, hand dominance, and hemispace on the kinematic properties of inward and outward reaches

Not just cybersickness: short-term effects of popular VR game mechanics on physical discomfort and reaction time

Beyond Feeling Sick: The Visual and Cognitive Aftereffects of Virtual Reality