Abstract:For a discrete symmetry that is anomalous under QCD, the domain walls produced in the early universe from its spontaneous breaking can naturally annihilate due to QCD instanton effects. The gravitational waves generated from wall annihilation have their amplitude and frequency determined by both the discrete symmetry breaking scale and the QCD scale. The evidence of stochastic gravitational waves at nanohertz observed by pulsar timing array experiments suggests that the discrete-symmetry-breaking scale is around 100 TeV, assuming the domain-wall explanation. The annihilation temperature is about 100 MeV, which could naturally be below the QCD phase transition temperature. We point out that the QCD phase transition within some domains with an effective large QCD θ angle could be a first-order one. To derive the phase diagram in θ and temperature, we adopt a phenomenological linear sigma model with three quark flavors. The domain-wall explanation for the NANOGrav, EPTA, PPTA and CPTA results hints at a first-order QCD phase transition, which predicts additional gravitational waves at higher frequencies. If the initial formation of domain walls is also a first-order process, this class of domain-wall models predicts an interesting gravitational wave spectroscopy with frequencies spanning more than ten orders of magnitude, from nanohertz to 100 Hz.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on two aspects:
1. **QCD Phase Transition and Gravitational Wave Signals**:
- The paper explores how domain walls generated by the spontaneous breaking of discrete symmetries in the early universe can be naturally annihilated through the QCD instanton effect. The annihilation of these domain walls will produce gravitational waves, and their amplitudes and frequencies are jointly determined by the discrete symmetry - breaking scale and the QCD scale.
- The author points out that the QCD phase transition in some domains may be a first - order phase transition, which depends on the effective large QCD θ angle within the domain. By using the linear σ - model (LSM q) with three quark flavors, the author derives the phase diagrams of θ and temperature and finds that the QCD phase transition within certain ranges of θ values is indeed a first - order phase transition.
2. **Interpretation of Pulsar Timing Array Experimental Results**:
- Pulsar timing array experiments (such as NANOGrav, EPTA, PPTA, and CPTA) have observed a stochastic gravitational - wave background in the nano - hertz frequency band. The paper assumes that these gravitational - wave backgrounds are generated by the collapse of domain walls and accordingly speculates that the discrete symmetry - breaking scale is approximately 100 TeV and the annihilation temperature is approximately 100 MeV.
- The author further points out that if the initial formation of domain walls is also a first - order process, then the gravitational - wave spectra predicted by such models will cover multiple orders of magnitude from nano - hertz to 100 Hz, with rich frequency characteristics.
### Main Research Contents
- **QCD - Anomalous Discrete Symmetry**: The paper discusses how QCD - anomalous discrete symmetry leads to the natural annihilation of domain walls and generates an effective potential through the QCD instanton effect, thereby breaking the symmetry.
- **Domain Wall Evolution**: It analyzes in detail the evolution processes of domain walls in both radiation - dominated and domain - wall - dominated cases, including the effects of domain - wall tension, friction, and Hubble damping.
- **QCD Phase Transition**: The properties of QCD phase transitions at different θ values are studied through the linear σ - model, especially the first - order phase transition when θ is close to π.
- **Gravitational - Wave Signals**: The gravitational - wave signals generated by domain - wall collapse, QCD phase transition, and potential phase - transition processes are calculated and compared with the results of pulsar timing array experiments.
### Key Conclusions
- The discrete symmetry - breaking scale is approximately 100 TeV, and the annihilation temperature is approximately 100 MeV, which is consistent with the gravitational - wave background observed in pulsar timing array experiments.
- The QCD phase transition in some domains may be a first - order phase transition, which will generate additional high - frequency gravitational - wave signals.
- If the initial formation of domain walls is also a first - order process, then the gravitational - wave spectra predicted by such models will cover multiple orders of magnitude from nano - hertz to 100 Hz, with unique frequency characteristics.
### Formula Examples
- **Domain - Wall Tension**:
\[
\sigma=\frac{16 \mu^{1 / 2} f^{N / 2+1}}{N^{3 / 2}}
\]
- **Maximum Biased Potential Difference**:
\[
V_{\text {max }}^{\text {bias }}=0.66 m_{\pi}^{2} f_{\pi}^{2} \approx(100.4 \text { MeV})^{4} \quad \text { (for even } N \text { )}
\]
- **QCD Phase - Transition Temperature**:
\[
T_{\text {dom }} \approx 45 \text { MeV }\left(\frac{A}{0.8}\right)^{1 / 2}\left(\frac{\sigma}{10^{16} \text { GeV }^{3}}\right)^{1 / 2}\left(\frac{g_{*}\left(T_{\text {dom }}\right)}{10}\right)^{-1 / 4}
\]
Through these studies, the paper provides a new perspective for understanding QCD phase transitions and gravitational - wave signals in the early universe.