Mechanisms of Intrusive Thinking
Michael C. Anderson,Adam Aron,Marie T. Banich,Kathleen T. Brady,Florian Schlagenhauf,Jonathan W. Schooler,Trevor W. Robbins
2020-01-01
Abstract:A classic defi nition of intrusive thinking is “any distinct, identifi able cognitive event that is unwanted, unintended, and recurrent. It interrupts the fl ow of thought, interferes in task performance, is associated with negative aff ect, and is diffi cult to control” (Clark 2005:4). While easy to understand and applicable to many cases, this defi nition does not seem to encompass the entire spectrum of intrusions. For example, intrusive thoughts may not always be experienced as unpleasant or unwanted, and may in some situations even be adaptive. This chapter revisits the defi nition of intrusive thinking, by systematically considering all the circumstances in which intrusions might occur, their manifestations across health and disorders, and develops an alternative, more inclusive defi nition of intrusions as being “interruptive, salient, experienced mental events.” It proposes that clinical intrusive thinking diff ers from its nonclinical form with regard to frequency, intensity, and maladaptive reappraisal. Further, it discusses the neurocognitive processes underlying intrusive thinking and its control, including memory processes involved in action control, working memory and long-term memory encoding, retrieval, and suppression. As part of this, current methodologies used to study intrusive thinking are evaluated and areas are highlighted where more research and/or technical innovation is needed. It concludes with a discussion of the theoretical, therapeutic, and sociocultural implications of intrusive thinking and its control. Group photos (top left to bottom right) Renée Visser, Michael Anderson, MarieHélène Monfi ls, Trevor Robbins, Daniela Schiller, Marie Banich, Adam Aron, Kathleen Brady, Jonathan Schooler, Florian Schlagenhauf, Quentin Huys, Michael Anderson, Daniela Schiller, Jonathan Schooler, Kathleen Brady, Quentin Huys, Florian Schlagenhauf, Marie-Hélène Monfi ls, Trevor Robbins, Renée Visser, Marie Banich From “Intrusive Thinking: From Molecules to Free Will,” edited by Peter W. Kalivas and Martin P. Paulus. Strüngmann Forum Reports, vol. 30, Julia R. Lupp, series editor. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. ISBN 978-0-262-54237-1 126 R. M. Visser et al.