Comparing Executive Functions in Children and Adolescents with Autism and ADHD—A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Claudia Ceruti,Alessandra Mingozzi,Nicoletta Scionti,Gian Marco Marzocchi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/children11040473

2024-04-15

Children

Abstract:Two neurodevelopmental conditions, autism spectrum disorder (ASD) and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), have been associated with executive function (EF) impairments but the specificity of their impairments is still controversial. The present meta-analysis aimed to identify the differences in EF profiles of ASD, ADHD, and ASD+ADHD in relation to a control group of individuals with typical development (TD) and to understand whether the EF performance could change depending upon the type of measure used to assess EF (performance tests vs. questionnaires). Results from 36 eligible studies revealed that ADHD and ASD showed more difficulties than the TD group in tests and, particularly, in questionnaires. No significant differences in the EF profile emerged between ASD and ADHD when assessed through neuropsychological tests (d = 0.02), while significant differences emerged when assessed through questionnaires, with ADHD having higher ratings than ASD (d = −0.34). EF questionnaires and neuropsychological tests may catch two different constructs of EF, with the former being more predictive of everyday life EF impairments. The comparison between the double diagnosis group (ADHD+ASD) and the clinical groups pointed out that the former has a more similar EF profile to the ADHD-alone one and that it shows more difficulties than ASD-alone.

pediatrics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems that this paper attempts to solve are as follows:

Both autism spectrum disorder (ASD) and attention - deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), these two neurodevelopmental disorders, are related to impairments in executive function (EF), but the specificity of these impairments remains controversial. The main purpose of this meta - analysis is to identify the differences in executive function among individuals with ASD, ADHD, and those with both ASD and ADHD, and compare them with the typically developing (TD) control group. In addition, the study also aims to explore whether the performance of executive function varies depending on the different assessment tools (i.e., performance tests vs. questionnaires).

Specifically, the researchers hope to answer the following questions:
1. First, examine the executive function performance of the two clinical groups (ADHD and ASD) relative to the TD group.
2. Second, by comparing the ADHD group and the ASD group, look for possible differences within a single executive function component.
3. Third, understand whether the differences in overall executive function performance change with the type of assessment measure: performance - based neuropsychological tests (used to assess the efficiency of high - order cognitive processes) vs. questionnaires (used to assess the success of goal pursuit).
4. Finally, study the executive function characteristics of the dual - diagnosis group (ADHD + ASD) to understand whether dual diagnosis shows higher, similar, or lower executive function impairments compared to single diagnosis (either ADHD or ASD only).

Through the exploration of these questions, the study aims to provide researchers and clinicians with a more in - depth understanding of whether executive function difficulties can be regarded as a specific marker associated with a particular disorder.