Abstract:This study highlight that phylogenetically closely related tree species may exhibit different nutrient‐acquisition strategies, and suggest a shift from an extensive nutrient‐acquisition mode depending more on absorptive fine roots to an intensive nutrient‐acquisition mode relying more on root exudation during stand development. Plant roots employ diverse strategies to acquire soil nutrients, including direct nutrient uptake through absorptive fine roots and root hairs, scavenging nutrients by forming symbioses with mycorrhizal fungi, and mining nutrients by releasing root exudates. However, whether these three strategies are differently coordinated among phylogenetically closely related tree species and how this coordination shifts with stand development remains largely unclear. To fill these knowledge gaps, we measured 13 root morphological, architectural, physiological and mycorrhizal traits tightly related to nutrient‐acquisition of three Pinus species (P. sylvestris var. mongolica, P. densiflora and P. tabuliformis) at young (20‐year‐old) and mature (50‐year‐old) stages planted in nutrient‐impoverished sandy soils, in Northeast China. We found that young trees had thinner absorptive fine roots and a higher specific root length than mature trees across three Pinus species, indicating that roots become morphologically less efficient in 'do it yourself' scavenging nutrients during stand development. Moreover, young stands had greater root length density and root area index, and mature stands had faster root‐exudation rates, suggesting that young stands rely more on expanding soil volumes to scavenge nutrients and mature stands depend more on root exudation to 'mine' nutrients. The three Pinus species exhibited different nutrient‐acquisition strategies at the mature stage; P. densiflora had higher root length density and root area index, and the other two Pinus species had greater ectomycorrhizal colonization rates. Synthesis. Our findings highlight that phylogenetically closely related tree species may exhibit different nutrient‐acquisition strategies and suggest a shift from an extensive nutrient‐acquisition mode depending more on absorptive fine roots to an intensive nutrient‐acquisition mode relying more on root exudation during stand development. 摘要植物根系采取多种策略获取土壤养分,包括根系和根毛直接吸收养分,与菌根真菌共生借助根外菌丝捕获养分,以及产生分泌物活化根际土壤养分。然而,目前尚不清楚亲缘关系相近的树种是否采取相似的养分获取策略以及树木的养分获取策略是否随其生长而发生改变。为此,本研究以中国"三北防护林"重要松属造林树种为研究对象,测定了中龄(20年生)和成熟(50年生)阶段的樟子松、赤松和油松的13个与养分获取紧密相关的根系形态、构型、生理以及菌根性状。本研究发现相比于成熟林,三种松属的中龄林吸收根具有更小的直径和更大的比根长,这一结果表明随林分生长,吸收根直接从土壤中获取养分的效率降低。另外,中龄林具有较高的吸收根根长密度和根表面积指数,而成熟林的根系分泌速率较快,这一结果表明中龄林主要通过增加吸收根在土壤中的探索面积来获取养分,成熟林则主要依赖根系分泌物来活化根际土壤养分。三个松属树种在成熟阶段具有不同的养分获取策略:赤松具有较大的吸收根根长密度和根表面积指数,而樟子松和油松具有较高的外生菌根真菌侵染率。结论:上述研究结果表明亲缘关系相近的树种可能表现出不同的土壤养分获取策略。随林分生长,根系的养分获取由更依靠吸收根扩大土壤养分吸收面积的粗放型策略转变为更依赖根系分泌物活化根际土壤养分的集约型策略。

Shifts from an extensive to an intensive root nutrient‐acquisition mode with stand development of three Pinus species

Effects of ontogenetic stage and leaf age on leaf functional traits and the relationships between traits in Pinus koraiensis

Species-Specific Responses of Root Morphology of Three Co-existing Tree Species to Nutrient Patches Reflect Their Root Foraging Strategies

Contrasting depth‐related fine root plastic responses to soil warming in a subtropical Chinese fir plantation

Nitrogen acquisition strategy shifts with tree age depending on root functional traits and soil properties in Larix principis-rupprechtii plantations

The Distribution pattern of carbon,nitrogen and phosphorus and the stoichiometry characteristics of Pinus massoniana plantation in different ages

Stoichiometric and nutrient resorption characteristics of dominant tree species in subtropical Chinese forests

[Stoichiometry of Carbon, Nitrogen and Phosphorus and Their Allometric Relationship Between Leaves and Fine Roots of Three Functional Tree Seedlings.]

Nitrogen and phosphorous dynamics with stand development of Pinus massoniana plantations in Southeast China

Litter and root traits control soil microbial composition and enzyme activities in 28 common subtropical tree species

[Foraging behavior of various tree species in heterogeneous nutrient environment related to light condition]

Root distribution characteristics of monoculture and mixture of Pinus tabuliformis and Robinia pseudoacacia plantation

Decoupling of uptake‐ and transport‐related traits in absorptive roots across coexisting herbaceous species in alpine meadows

Responses of Belowground Fine Root Biomass and Morphology in Robinia pseudoacacia L. Plantations to Aboveground Environmental Factors

[Effects of litterfall and root input on soil physical and chemical properties in Pinus massoniana plantations in Three Gorges Reservoir Area, China]

Variation of carbon ꎬ nitrogen and phosphorus stoichiometric characteristics of fine roots in Masson pine and Chinese fir plantations with soil depth

Leaf resorption efficiency in relation to foliar and soil nutrient concentrations and stoichiometry of Cunninghamia lanceolata with stand development in southern China

Study on the causes of growth differences in three conifers after the rainy season in the Xiong'an New Area

Relative position of seeds driven the seedling growth are mediated by root–leaf traits

Growth and nutrient characteristics of Pinus massoniana in a Southern red soil

Growth, morphological traits and mycorrhizal colonization of fine roots respond differently to nitrogen addition in a slash pine plantation in subtropical China