Effect of Rockfall Spatial Representation on the Accuracy and Reliability of Susceptibility Models (The Case of the Haouz Dorsale Calcaire, Morocco)

Youssef El Miloudi,Younes El Kharim,Ali Bounab,Rachid El Hamdouni

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/land13020176

IF: 3.905

2024-02-03

Land

Abstract:Rockfalls can cause loss of life and material damage. In Northern Morocco, rockfalls and rock avalanche-deposits are frequent, especially in the Dorsale Calcaire morpho-structural unit, which is mostly formed by Jurassic limestone and dolostone formations. In this study, we focus exclusively on its northern segment, conventionally known as "the Haouz subunit". First, a rockfall inventory was conducted. Then, two datasets were prepared: one covering exclusively the source area and the other representing the entirety of the mass movements (source + propagation area). Two algorithms were then used to build rockfall susceptibility models (RSMs). The first one (Logistic Regression: LR) yielded the most unreliable results, where the RSM derived from the source area dataset significantly outperformed the one based on the entirety of the rockfall affected area, despite the lack of significant visual differences between both models. However, the RSMs produced using Artificial Neural Networks (ANNs) were more or less similar in terms of accuracy, despite the source area model being more conservative. This result is unexpected given the fact that previous studies proved the robustness of the LR algorithm and the sensitivity of ANN models. However, we believe that the non-linear correlation between the spatial distribution of the rockfall propagation area and that of the conditioning factors used to compute the models explains why modeling rockfalls in particular differs from other types of landslides.

environmental studies

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper primarily explores the impact of spatial representation methods of rockfall on the accuracy and reliability of Rockfall Susceptibility Models (RSMs). The study focuses on the Haouz Dorsale Calcaire area in northern Morocco. ### Research Background and Objectives - **Study Area**: Located in the northern section of the Dorsale Calcaire structural unit in northern Morocco (Haouz Dorsale Calcaire), this area is characterized by Jurassic limestone and dolomite strata, with frequent occurrences of rockfalls and rockfall deposits. - **Research Objective**: To evaluate how spatial representation methods of rockfall affect the accuracy and reliability of rockfall susceptibility models. Models are built using two different datasets: one containing only data from the rockfall source areas, and the other covering the entire rockfall process (source area + propagation area). ### Methodology - **Model Construction**: - Rockfall susceptibility models are constructed using **Logistic Regression (LR)** and **Artificial Neural Networks (ANNs)**. - The dataset is divided into two parts: one part contains only information from the rockfall source areas, and the other includes the complete rockfall process. - **Validation Method**: The models are validated using the remaining 30% of rockfall data that was not involved in the training process. ### Main Findings - **Logistic Regression Results**: Models built based on rockfall source area data performed better than those based on the complete rockfall process data. Although the visual differences between the two are minimal, the source area models are more reliable in performance. - **Artificial Neural Network Results**: Models constructed using ANNs showed similar accuracy, but the source area models were more conservative. This indicates that ANN models are more sensitive to changes in input data. - **Nonlinear Relationships**: The study suggests that the nonlinear correlation between the spatial distribution of rockfall propagation areas and their conditional factors explains why rockfall modeling differs from other types of landslides. ### Conclusion By comparing models constructed under two different spatial representation methods of rockfall, the paper reveals the importance of rockfall source and propagation areas in building rockfall susceptibility models. It also points out that ANN models are more sensitive to changes in input data. These findings are significant for improving rockfall risk assessment.

Effect of Rockfall Spatial Representation on the Accuracy and Reliability of Susceptibility Models (The Case of the Haouz Dorsale Calcaire, Morocco)

Integrated hazard assessment of rockfall incidents in the Cap Aokas Cliff Region

A comparative modeling of landslides susceptibility at a meso-scale using frequency ratio and analytic hierarchy process models in geographic information system: the case of African Alpine Mountains (Rif, Morocco)

The importance of investigating causative factors and training data selection for accurate landslide susceptibility assessment: the case of Ain Lahcen commune (Tetouan, Northern Morocco)

Landslide susceptibility mapping using GIS-based statistical and machine learning modeling in the city of Sidi Abdellah, Northern Algeria

GIS-based statistical and limit equilibrium models in the assessment of slope stability and landslide susceptibility: the case study of the Aomar Miocene basin, Bouira, Algeria

Landslide susceptibility mapping using GIS Matrix Method and Frequency Ratio, application in the marly context of Moulay Yacoub Region, Morocco

Landslide Susceptibility Mapping Using Multi-Criteria Decision-Making (MCDM), Statistical, and Machine Learning Models in the Aube Department, France

Integrated approaches for flash flood susceptibility mapping: spatial modeling and comparative analysis of statistical and machine learning models. A case study of the Rheraya watershed, Morocco

Landslide Risk Assessments through Multicriteria Analysis

A novel hybrid artificial intelligence approach based on the rotation forest ensemble and naïve Bayes tree classifiers for a landslide susceptibility assessment in Langao County, China

Assessment of the effects of training data selection on the landslide susceptibility mapping: a comparison between support vector machine (SVM), logistic regression (LR) and artificial neural networks (ANN)

Managing Rockfall Hazard on Strategic Linear Stakes: How Can Machine Learning Help to Better Predict Periods of Increased Rockfall Activity?

Advanced modeling for flash flood susceptibility mapping using remote sensing and GIS techniques: a case study in Northeast Algeria

Rock fall susceptibility assessment along a mountainous road: an evaluation of bivariate statistic, analytical hierarchy process and frequency ratio

Empirical quantification of rockfall reach probability: objective determination of appropriate topographic descriptor

Landslide Hazard Assessment in the Heterogeneous Geomorphological and Environmental Context of the Rif Region, Morocco – A Machine Learning Approach

GIS-based rockfall hazard zones modeling along the coastal Gulf of Aqaba Region, Egypt

Characterizing Seismic Activity From a Rock Cliff With Unsupervised Learning

A Monte Carlo simulation approach for effective assessment of flyrock based on intelligent system of neural network

Conditioning factor determination for mapping and prediction of landslide susceptibility using machine learning algorithms