Abstract:Research with athletes and coaches has found that attentional focus strategies are more complex than using an internal or external focus exclusively. Recently Becker et al. [2020, March 1. The effects of attentional focus in the preparation and execution of a standing long jump. Psychological Research, 84(2), 285-291] found that switching attentional focus from internal in movement preparation to external during movement execution provided a benefit over internal focus and control conditions. The purpose of this study was to investigate the effects of attentional switching on motor skill acquisition. 79 participants were randomly divided into an internal (INT), external (EXT), or switching group (IES). Individuals performed 80 acquisition trials of a golf chipping task with their prescribed attentional focus during preparation and execution. 24-hours later 10-trial retention and transfer tests were performed. The primary analysis revealed significant improvement during acquisition (p < .001) but no significant differences between attentional focus groups during acquisition, retention, or transfer. A secondary analysis was performed with individuals low in attentional focus adherence removed (<60%). Groups significantly improved during acquisition (p < .001). For retention IES significantly outperformed INT (p < .05). These results suggest that the detrimental effects of an internal focus are only found during skill execution and not movement preparation. It is possible for learners to benefit from both an internal and external focus so long as the cues are provided during the correct phase of skill performance.Highlights Attentional focus is much more complex than using either an internal or external focus of attention. This study investigated the effects of switching attention during skill acquisition from an internal to external focus.A preliminary analysis revealed no significant differences between attentional focus groups of internal, external, or switching. One reason for this finding was the poor adherence to the prescribed focus cue.A secondary analysis where low adherence individuals were removed revealed a significant difference between the switching group and the internal focus group during retention.These finding suggest that the detrimental effects associated with an internal focus of attention are exclusive to using the focus during task execution. It is possible that an internal focus can still facilitate learning so long as an external focus is used during movement execution.

A proximal external focus does not benefit skilled skiers

Resolving the Centipede's Dilemma: external focus distance and expertise in applied, continuous skills

Utilising an internal focus of attention during preparation and an external focus during execution may facilitate motor learning

Location versus task relevance: The impact of differing internal focus of attention instructions on motor performance

Reporting bias, not external focus: A robust Bayesian meta-analysis and systematic review of the external focus of attention literature.

An external focus of attention is a conditio sine qua non for athletes: a response to Carson, Collins, and Toner (2015)

Golf skill learning: An external focus of attention enhances performance and motivation

External vs Internal Focus of Attention in Procedural Skills Learning: A Randomized Study

The effects of attentional focus in the preparation and execution of a standing long jump

An external focus of attention enhances table tennis backhand stroke accuracy in low-skilled players

Mind over body: Creating an external focus for sport skills

Focus of attention and its impact on movement behaviour

An external focus promotes motor learning of an aiming task in individuals with hearing impairments

Sequential focus of attention instructions influenced motor performance of volleyball setting despite direction of focus but dependent on motor expertise of the player

Expert and Novice Performers Respond Differently to Attentional Focus Cues for Speed Jump Roping

A meta-analysis on immediate effects of attentional focus on motor tasks performance

Attentional Focus in Complex Skill Learning

Impact of Attentional Focus on Dance Performance: A Critically Appraised Topic

An external focus of attention compared to an internal focus of attention improves anticipatory postural adjustments among people post-stroke

The influence of attentional focus on the development of skill representation in a complex action

External Focus of Attention Influences Cortical Activity Associated With Single Limb Balance Performance