Abstract:Objective: The proper handling of missing values is critical to delivering reliable estimates and decisions, especially in high-stakes fields such as clinical research. In response to the increasing diversity and complexity of data, many researchers have developed deep learning (DL)-based imputation techniques. We conducted a systematic review to evaluate the use of these techniques, with a particular focus on the types of data, intending to assist healthcare researchers from various disciplines in dealing with missing data. Materials and methods: We searched five databases (MEDLINE, Web of Science, Embase, CINAHL, and Scopus) for articles published prior to February 8, 2023 that described the use of DL-based models for imputation. We examined selected articles from four perspectives: data types, model backbones (i.e., main architectures), imputation strategies, and comparisons with non-DL-based methods. Based on data types, we created an evidence map to illustrate the adoption of DL models. Results: Out of 1822 articles, a total of 111 were included, of which tabular static data (29%, 32/111) and temporal data (40%, 44/111) were the most frequently investigated. Our findings revealed a discernible pattern in the choice of model backbones and data types, for example, the dominance of autoencoder and recurrent neural networks for tabular temporal data. The discrepancy in imputation strategy usage among data types was also observed. The "integrated" imputation strategy, which solves the imputation task simultaneously with downstream tasks, was most popular for tabular temporal data (52%, 23/44) and multi-modal data (56%, 5/9). Moreover, DL-based imputation methods yielded a higher level of imputation accuracy than non-DL methods in most studies. Conclusion: The DL-based imputation models are a family of techniques, with diverse network structures. Their designation in healthcare is usually tailored to data types with different characteristics. Although DL-based imputation models may not be superior to conventional approaches across all datasets, it is highly possible for them to achieve satisfactory results for a particular data type or dataset. There are, however, still issues with regard to portability, interpretability, and fairness associated with current DL-based imputation models.

Siamese autoencoder architecture for the imputation of data missing not at random

Multiple Imputation with Denoising Autoencoder using Metamorphic Truth and Imputation Feedback

DSAE-Impute: Learning Discriminative Stacked Autoencoders for Imputing Single-cell RNA-seq Data

mDAE : modified Denoising AutoEncoder for missing data imputation

MIDIA: exploring denoising autoencoders for missing data imputation

Proposition of a Theoretical Model for Missing Data Imputation using Deep Learning and Evolutionary Algorithms

Imputation of Missing Values in Training Data Using Variational Autoencoder

$Ae^2I$: A Double Autoencoder for Imputation of Missing Values

SICE: an improved missing data imputation technique

An Intelligent Missing Data Imputation Techniques: A Review

Missing-Data Imputation with Position-Encoding Denoising Auto-encoders for Industrial Processes

The MIDAS Touch: Accurate and Scalable Missing-Data Imputation with Deep Learning

SADI: Similarity-Aware Diffusion Model-Based Imputation for Incomplete Temporal EHR Data

Do we really need imputation in AutoML predictive modeling?

Are deep learning models superior for missing data imputation in large surveys? Evidence from an empirical comparison

Smoothed LSTM-AE: A spatio-temporal deep model for multiple time-series missing imputation

Multistage Large Segment Imputation Framework Based on Deep Learning and Statistic Metrics

Autoencoder Imputation of Missing Heterogeneous Data for Alzheimer's Disease Classification

Handling missing values in healthcare data: A systematic review of deep learning-based imputation techniques

AdImpute: An Imputation Method for Single-Cell RNA-Seq Data Based on Semi-Supervised Autoencoders

A multistage deep imputation framework for missing values large segment imputation with statistical metrics