Symptoms without illness: Fear of flying among fighter pilots

Arnold D. Bucove,Richard P. Maioriello

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/bf01562963

1970-12-01

Abstract:Conclusions of illness and/or application of psychiatric diagnoses are pragmatically important to their recipients, especially in a military setting. Six out of seven fliers who were afraid to fly their aircraft had somatic complaints. Somatic complaints were acceptable in the fighter pilot milieu, but fear of flying and psychiatric complaints were not acceptable in the pilot milieu. In these cases, somatic complaints were not accepted by the pilots' physicians, but a fear of flying was acceptable by them. In the course of their transactions with their physicians, the pilots changed from somatic symptoms to a recognition of their underlying fear of flying. The symptoms cleared when they were no longer useful and were retained by only, two pilots whose gains must be considered quite primary (viz., their careers and lives). By Air Force terminology, “illness” was not an applicable term for the five men who did not retain symptoms. The predicaments of all seven of these men are not better understood or treated as “illness”. In any context, the symptoms are better understood as communication: “I don't want to fly jet fighters anymore”. These symptoms had their own reward.

psychiatry