Abstract:Engineering identical genetic circuits into different species typically results in large differences in performance due to the unique cellular environmental context of each host, a phenomenon known as the "chassis-effect" or "context-dependency". A better understanding of how genomic and physiological contexts underpin the chassis-effect will improve biodesign strategies across diverse microorganisms. Here, we combined a pangenomic-based gene expression analysis with quantitative measurements of performance from an engineered genetic inverter device to uncover how genome structure and function relate to the observed chassis-effect across six closely related Stutzerimonas hosts. Our results reveal that genome architecture underpins divergent responses between our chosen non-model bacterial hosts to the engineered device. Specifically, differential expression of the core genome, gene clusters shared between all hosts, was found to be the main source of significant concordance to the observed differential genetic device performance, whereas specialty genes from respective accessory genomes were not significant. A data-driven investigation revealed that genes involved in denitrification and components of trans-membrane transporter proteins were among the most differentially expressed gene clusters between hosts in response to the genetic device. Our results show that the chassis-effect can be traced along differences among the most conserved genome-encoded functions and that these differences create a unique biodesign space among closely related species.IMPORTANCEContemporary synthetic biology endeavors often default to a handful of model organisms to host their engineered systems. Model organisms such as Escherichia coli serve as attractive hosts due to their tractability but do not necessarily provide the ideal environment to optimize performance. As more novel microbes are domesticated for use as biotechnology platforms, synthetic biologists are urged to explore the chassis-design space to optimize their systems and deliver on the promises of synthetic biology. The consequences of the chassis-effect will therefore only become more relevant as the field of biodesign grows. In our work, we demonstrate that the performance of a genetic device is highly dependent on the host environment it operates within, promoting the notion that the chassis can be considered a design variable to tune circuit function. Importantly, our results unveil that the chassis-effect can be traced along similarities in genome architecture, specifically the shared core genome. Our study advocates for the exploration of the chassis-design space and is a step forward to empowering synthetic biologists with knowledge for more efficient exploration of the chassis-design space to enable the next generation of broad-host-range synthetic biology.

Context-dependent redesign of robust synthetic gene circuits

Fine Tuning Genetic Circuits via Host Context and RBS Modulation

Model-guided gene circuit design for engineering genetically stable cell populations in diverse applications

Scaling up genetic circuit design for cellular computing: advances and prospects

Synthetic Genetic Circuits for Programmable Biological Functionalities

Control theory meets synthetic biology

Controlling cell-to-cell variability with synthetic gene circuits

Enhancing circuit stability under growth feedback with supplementary repressive regulation

Pangenomic landscapes shape performances of a synthetic genetic circuit across Stutzerimonas species

Synthetic Gene Circuits: Design with Directed Evolution

A coarse-grained bacterial cell model for resource-aware analysis and design of synthetic gene circuits

Mitigating Host Burden of Genetic Circuits by Engineering Autonegatively Regulated Parts and Improving Functional Prediction

Synthetic robust perfect adaptation achieved by negative feedback coupling with linear weak positive feedback

Build to understand: synthetic approaches to biology.

Perspectives on Synthetic Protein Circuits in Mammalian Cells

Designing biological circuits: from principles to applications

Effects of growth feedback on gene circuits: A dynamical understanding

Reprogramming genetic circuits using space

Design and Control of Synthetic Biological Systems

Combining positive and negative regulation for modular and robust biomolecular control architectures

Understanding resource competition to achieve predictable synthetic gene expression in eukaryotes