Abstract:The Hubble Space Telescope (HST) finds galaxies whose Tolman dimming exceeds 10 mag. Could evolution alone explain these as our ancestor galaxies or could they be representatives of quite a different dynasty whose descendants are no longer prominent today? We explore the latter hypothesis and argue that surface brightness selection effects naturally bring into focus quite different dynasties from different redshifts. Thus, the HST z = 7 galaxies could be examples of galaxies whose descendants are both too small and too choked with dust to be recognizable in our neighbourhood easily today. Conversely, the ancestors of the Milky Way and its obvious neighbours would have completely sunk below the sky at z > 1.2, unless they were more luminous in the past, although their diffused light could account for the missing re‐ionization flux. This Succeeding Prominent Dynasties Hypothesis (SPDH) fits the existing observations both naturally and well even without evolution, including the bizarre distributions of galaxy surface brightness found in deep fields, the angular size ∼(1 + z)−1 law, ‘downsizing’ which turns out to be an ‘illusion’ in the sense that it does not imply evolution, ‘infant mortality’, that is, the discrepancy between stars born and stars seen, the existence of ‘red nuggets’, and finally the recently discovered and unexpected excess of quasar absorption line damped Lyα systems at high redshift. If galaxies were not significantly brighter in the past and the SPDH were true, then a large proportion of galaxies could remain sunk from sight, possibly at all redshifts, and these sunken galaxies could supply the missing re‐ionization flux. We show that fishing these sunken galaxies out of the sky by their optical emissions alone is practically impossible, even when they are nearby. More ingenious methods are needed to detect them. It follows that disentangling galaxy evolution through studying ever higher redshift galaxies may be a forlorn hope because one could be comparing young oranges with old apples, not ancestors with their true descendants.

The galaxy ancestor problem

A Study on the Multicolour Evolution of Red Sequence Galaxy Populations: Insights from Hydrodynamical Simulations and Semi-Analytical Models

Quasiparticle Energy Dispersion and Shadow Peaks in a Doped SO(5) Symmetric Ladder

Are disappearing dwarfs just lying low ?

The Morphological Evolution, AGN Fractions, Dust Content, Environments, and Downsizing of Massive Green Valley Galaxies at 0.5<z<2.5 in 3D-HST/CANDELS

Relating galaxies across different redshift to study galaxy evolution

Nonlinear Stability of Bifurcating Front Solutions for the Taylor-Couette Problem

The evolving relations between size, mass, surface density, and star formation in 3x10^4 galaxies since z=2

The diverse evolutionary paths of simulated high-z massive, compact galaxies to z=0

Galaxy Zoo: evidence for diverse star formation histories through the green valley

The Evolution of Galactic Discs

Morphological evolution in situ: Disk-dominated cluster red sequences at z ~ 1.25

Faint field galaxies: an explanation of the faint blue excess using number evolution models

A semi-analytical perspective on massive red galaxies: I. Assembly history, environment & redshift evolution

The Evolution of Post-Starburst Galaxies from $z\sim1$ to the Present

Globular clusters, satellite galaxies and stellar haloes from early dark matter peaks

Cosmic Evolution of Size and Velocity Dispersion for Early Type Galaxies

Old Stellar Populations in Nearby Dwarf Galaxies

Probing galaxy evolution from $z=0$ to $z\simeq10$ through galaxy scaling relations in three L-Galaxies flavours

Galaxy evolution in the high redshift, colour-selected cluster RzCS 052 at z=1.02

Where are the Fossils of the First Galaxies? II. True Fossils, Ghost Halos, and the Missing Bright Satellites