Arsenic immobilization and removal in contaminated soil using zero-valent iron or magnetic biochar amendment followed by dry magnetic separation

Jining Li,Ying Zhang,Fenghe Wang,Lei Wang,Jing Liu,Yohey Hashimoto,Masaaki Hosomi
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.144521
2021-05-01
Abstract:<p>The potential of using zero-valent iron (ZVI) or a Fe<sub>3</sub>O<sub>4</sub>-loaded magnetic biochar to stabilize arsenic (As) in contaminated soil was investigated in the processes of incubation trial, chemical extraction, pot experiments with ryegrass growth. Additionally, a dry magnetic separation technique was applied to verify the possible permanent removal of As from the bulk soil. Results showed the ZVI amendment greatly reduced the As leaching, and the leached concentration became much lower than the Japanese environment standard (10 μg/L) after 180 days of incubation. Contrarily, the magnetic biochar amendment readily increased the As leachability due to the changes in pH, dissolved organic carbon, and soluble P and Si. The ZVI had a greater effect over the magnetic biochar, supported by the significantly reduced As leachability in the combined amendments. Furthermore, results from sequential extraction analysis indicate that both amendments significantly decreased the available As in (NH<sub>4</sub>)<sub>2</sub>SO<sub>4</sub> and NH<sub>4</sub>H<sub>2</sub>PO<sub>4</sub> extraction and increased the As bound to amorphous Fe oxides. But ZVI amendment alone performed better than magnetic biochar amendment alone. Plant growth experiment showed that the ZVI amendment enhanced ryegrass growth and significantly increased the ryegrass biomass. However, the magnetic biochar amendment resulted in an adverse effect on the ryegrass root growth, probably due to a marked enhancement of salinity. Meanwhile, the As uptake by ryegrass was significantly reduced in both ZVI and magnetic biochar-amended soils. Results of dry magnetic separation showed that averaged 20% and 25% of total As could be retrieved from ZVI and magnetic biochar amended soil, respectively; and the As bound to amorphous Fe oxides was the main retrieved fraction. This study indicated that ZVI or magnetic biochar could be applied as a promising amendment for reducing (phyto)availability of As in soil, and dry magnetic separation could be served as an alternative option for permanently removing As.</p>
environmental sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve are as follows: The research aims to explore the effects of using zero - valent iron (ZVI) or magnetic biochar (MB) to stabilize arsenic (As) - contaminated soil, and verify the possibility of permanently removing arsenic from the whole soil through dry magnetic separation technology. Specifically, the research objectives include: 1. **Compare the effects of ZVI or MB addition on arsenic immobilization**: Through incubation tests, chemical extraction and pot experiments of planting ryegrass, evaluate the immobilization effects of ZVI or MB addition on arsenic in contaminated soil. 2. **Study the physical removal effect of dry magnetic separation technology on arsenic in soil**: Explore whether dry magnetic separation technology can effectively and permanently remove arsenic from soil. ### Research background Soil arsenic pollution is usually caused by human activities. Arsenic has no physiological benefits for plants, animals and humans, and even a trace amount can have adverse effects. Therefore, it is listed as one of the priority - controlled harmful pollutants by the World Health Organization. In - situ stabilization is a mild method to control the environmental risks of arsenic - contaminated soil. By adding amendments to the soil, arsenic is fixed in a stable solid phase through adsorption, complexation and precipitation, etc., thereby reducing its mobility and bioavailability. ### Research methods - **Material preparation**: The soil used in the research was from a soil treatment plant of DOWA ECOSYSTEM in Japan. The soil samples were dried, ground and sieved. ZVI and magnetic biochar were used as amendments respectively. - **Soil improvement and extraction**: Through incubation tests, 2% ZVI or 2% magnetic biochar was added to the soil, and a control group and a combined treatment group (ZVI + magnetic biochar) were set up. The concentration changes of water - soluble arsenic and other elements were regularly sampled and analyzed. - **Plant growth experiment**: By planting ryegrass, the effects of different treatments on plant growth and arsenic absorption were evaluated. - **Dry magnetic separation**: After 180 - day incubation, a U - shaped magnet was used to separate the arsenic - containing magnetic substances from the soil, and their components were analyzed. ### Main findings - **ZVI significantly reduces the water - solubility of arsenic**: The addition of ZVI significantly reduced the water - solubility of arsenic, making its concentration lower than the Japanese environmental standard (10 μg/L). - **Magnetic biochar increases the water - solubility of arsenic**: The addition of magnetic biochar increased the water - solubility of arsenic instead, which may be due to changes in pH value, dissolved organic carbon, soluble phosphorus and silicon. - **ZVI promotes ryegrass growth**: The addition of ZVI significantly increased the biomass of ryegrass, while magnetic biochar inhibited root growth, which may be due to the increase in salinity. - **Dry magnetic separation effectively removes arsenic**: Dry magnetic separation technology can remove an average of 20% to 25% of the total arsenic from the soil, mainly removing arsenic bound to amorphous iron oxides. ### Conclusion The research results show that ZVI or magnetic biochar can be used as effective amendments to reduce the bioavailability of arsenic in soil. As an auxiliary means, dry magnetic separation technology can achieve permanent removal of arsenic, providing new ideas for the treatment of arsenic - contaminated soil.