Evaluation of the indoor environment in a historic museum during the COVID-19 lockdown in Northwest England

Sura Al-Maiyah,D. Brett Martinson,Hisham Elkadi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/09613218.2024.2339207

IF: 3.9

2024-04-29

Building Research & Information

Abstract:Monitoring the quality of the indoor environment is a practice commonly adopted by museums as part of operational risk management. Recorded environmental data are often used to assess the safety of the indoor environment for artefacts, and their suitability for visitors' comfort. Previous studies reported monitoring campaigns assessing the performance of museums and level of compliance with regulatory standards. These analyses were typically conducted in normal circumstances assessing indoor microclimate quality under normal operating procedures. Museum closures during the 2020 pandemic and the global lockdown measures, introduced by governments, presented the heritage sector with an unprecedented situation with empty galleries where collections, in several museums, were held 'dormant' in free-running environments. Assessing the indoor environment in such exceptional circumstances offers a unique insight into the performance of these heritage repositories in other unpredicted situations and potential opportunities for microclimate optimization. This paper reports the results of an extended pre and post-pandemic monitoring that was performed in a historic museum in Northwest England. It contributes to the ongoing universal debate about the application of standardized strict environmental guidelines and the shift towards more contextualized standards in museums in the face of the decline in heritage funding and the pledges for carbon reductions.

construction & building technology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the changes in the indoor environment of a historic museum in the Northwest of England during its closure due to the COVID-19 pandemic and assesses the impact of this unique situation on the museum's collections.

### Issues the Paper Attempts to Address

1. **Assessing Changes in the Indoor Environment During Special Periods**: The study focuses on the changes in the indoor environment caused by the museum's closure during the COVID-19 pandemic. This includes changes in key parameters such as temperature and humidity.

2. **Analyzing the Impact of These Changes on Collections**: The paper further evaluates whether these unique indoor environmental changes could adversely affect the museum's collections, particularly those made of organic materials, such as potentially leading to mold growth or chemical degradation.

3. **Exploring the Flexibility of Environmental Control Standards**: Based on the above assessments, the paper also discusses whether it is necessary for museums to strictly adhere to existing environmental control standards in resource-limited situations, and whether there is room to adopt more contextual standards to optimize microclimate conditions in support of energy-saving and emission reduction goals.

4. **Collecting Empirical Data to Support Decision-Making**: The paper emphasizes the importance of the environmental monitoring data collected during the pandemic. This data can serve as empirical evidence for assessing the safety of collections under different environmental conditions, thereby supporting future decisions regarding environmental control policies.

Through the above analysis, the paper aims to provide new perspectives and evidence for museum environmental management, particularly in balancing the needs of collection preservation and energy-saving and emission reduction when facing resource constraints and climate change challenges.