Abstract:BackgroundProblem-based curricula have provoked controversy amongst educators and students regarding outcome in medical graduates, supporting the need for longitudinal evaluation of curriculum change. As part of a longitudinal evaluation program at the University of Adelaide, a mixed method approach was used to compare the graduate outcomes of two curriculum cohorts: traditional lecture-based ‘old’ and problem-based ‘new’ learning.MethodsGraduates were asked to self-assess preparedness for hospital practice and consent to a comparative analysis of their work-place based assessments from their intern year. Comparative data were extracted from 692 work-place based assessments for 124 doctors who graduated from the University of Adelaide Medical School between 2003 and 2006.ResultsSelf-assessment: Overall, graduates of the lecture-based curriculum rated the medical program significantly higher than graduates of the problem-based curriculum. However, there was no significant difference between the two curriculum cohorts with respect to their preparedness in 13 clinical skills. There were however, two areas where the cohorts rated their preparedness in the 13 broad practitioner competencies as significantly different: problem-based graduates rated themselves as better prepared in their ‘awareness of legal and ethical issues’ and the lecture-based graduates rated themselves better prepared in their ‘understanding of disease processes’.Work-place based assessment: There were no significant differences between the two curriculum cohorts for ‘Appropriate Level of Competence’ and ‘Overall Appraisal’. Of the 14 work-place based assessment skills assessed for competence, no significant difference was found between the cohorts.ConclusionsThe differences in the perceived preparedness for hospital practice of two curriculum cohorts do not reflect the work-place based assessments of their competence as interns. No significant difference was found between the two cohorts in relation to their knowledge and clinical skills. However results suggest a trend in ‘communication with peers and colleagues in other disciplines’ (χ2 (3, N = 596) =13.10, p = 0.056) that requires further exploration. In addition we have learned that student confidence in a new curriculum may impact on their self-perception of preparedness, while not affecting their actual competence.

Acceptability and feasibility of an evaluation table to assess the competency of general medicine interns during ambulatory rotations in Brest

[Evaluation of the theoretical teaching of postgraduate medical students in France]

[Validity and reproducibility of two direct observation assessment forms for evaluation of internal medicine residents' clinical skills]

Validation of French versions of the 15-item picker patient experience questionnaire for adults, teenagers, and children inpatients

How was the intern year?: self and clinical assessment of four cohorts, from two medical curricula

A four-Axis-Method to Evaluate a Part of an Undergraduate Medical Students' Curriculum

Evaluation of orthopaedic residents from SOCLE phase to osteosynthesis simulation: feedback from the AO course

The reliability of workplace-based assessment in postgraduate medical education and training: a national evaluation in general practice in the United Kingdom

Design and pilot implementation of an evaluation tool assessing professionalism, communication and collaboration during a unique global health elective

Exploration of evaluation based on entrustable professional activities during internship for eight-year program undergraduates of clinical medicine

General practice undergraduate and vocational training: ambulatory teaching and trainers' curriculum and remuneration - a cross-sectional study among 30 member countries of WONCA Europe

[Association between students' clinical performance and their success in the computerized national ranking tests: A single-center retrospective cohort study]

Development and implementation of an objective structured clinical examination (OSCE) in CMF-surgery for dental students

Competence-based teaching and learning in the outpatient clinic: development of a clinical elective in ambulatory medicine

[Last year of residency for oncologists: Overview and perspectives]

How students perceive medical competences: a cross-cultural study between the Medical Course in Portugal and African Portuguese Speaking Countries

Logbooks alone are not enough: initial experience with implementing a logbook for medical students in a clinical internship in gynecology and obstetrics

The "General practitioner learning stations"-development, implementation and optimization of an innovative format for sustainable teaching in general practice

An online training and feedback module enhances the musculoskeletal examination performance of medical interns

Introducing an assessment tool based on a full set of end-of-training EPAs to capture the workplace performance of final-year medical students

Assessment of patients' self-perceived intensive care unit discomforts: Validation of the 18-item version of the IPREA