Abstract:A cornerstone of human intelligence is the ability to flexibly adjust our cognition and behavior as our goals change. For instance, achieving some goals requires efficiency, while others require caution. Adapting to these changing goals require corresponding adjustments in cognitive control (e.g., levels of attention, response thresholds). However, adjusting our control to meet new goals comes at a cost: we are better at achieving a goal in isolation than when transitioning between goals. The source of these remains poorly understood, and the bulk of our understanding of such costs comes from settings in which participants transition between discrete task sets, rather than performance goals. Across four experiments, we show that adjustments in continuous control states incur a performance cost, and that a dynamical systems model can explain the source of these costs. Participants performed a single cognitively demanding task under varying performance goals (e.g., to be fast or to be accurate). We modeled control allocation to include a dynamic process of adjusting from one’s current control state to a target state for a given performance goal. By incorporating inertia into this adjustment process, our model accounts for our empirical findings that people under-shoot their target control state more (i.e., exhibit larger adjustment costs) when (a) goals switch rather than remain fixed over a block (Study 1); (b) target control states are more distant from one another (Study 2); (c) less time is given to adjust to the new goal (Study 3); and (d) when anticipating having to switch goals more frequently (Study 4). Our findings characterize the costs of adjusting control to meet changing goals, and show that these costs can emerge directly from cognitive control dynamics. In so doing, they shed new light on the sources of and constraints on flexibility in human goal-directed behavior.

Insights into control over cognitive flexibility from studies of task-switching

Cognitive flexibility across the lifespan: developmental differences in the neural basis of sustained and transient control processes during task switching

Principles of cognitive control over task focus and task switching

Cognitive Flexibility: Neurobehavioral Correlates of Changing One's Mind.

Learning Cognitive Flexibility: Neural Substrates of Adapting Switch-Readiness to Time-varying Demands

One cannot simply 'be flexible': regulating control parameters requires learning

Investigating the shift between externally and internally oriented cognition: a novel task-switching paradigm

Learned switch readiness via concurrent activation of task sets: Evidence from task specificity and memory load

Learning and Cognitive Flexibility: Frontostriatal Function and Monoaminergic Modulation

Double task switching: An investigation into the effects of similarity and task-rule congruency on cognitive flexibility

Development and Plasticity of Cognitive Flexibility in Early and Middle Childhood

Measuring cognitive flexibility: A brief review of neuropsychological, self-report, and neuroscientific approaches

Cognitive and behavioural flexibility: neural mechanisms and clinical considerations

Is Cognitive Flexibility Equivalent to Shifting? Investigating Cognitive Flexibility in Multiple Domains

Mapping common and distinct brain correlates among cognitive flexibility tasks: concordant evidence from meta-analyses

Control adjustment costs limit goal flexibility: Empirical evidence and a computational account

A cognitive control framework for understanding emotion regulation flexibility.

Aperiodic neural activity reflects metacontrol in task-switching

Distinct roles of prefrontal cortex neurons in set shifting

Mechanisms underlying flexible adaptation of cognitive control: behavioral and neuroimaging evidence in a flanker task