Performance of Soil Moisture Sensors at Different Salinity Levels: Comparative Analysis and Calibration
Qiuju Qi,Hai Yang,Quanping Zhou,Xiaole Han,Zhengyang Jia,Yuehua Jiang,Zi Chen,Lili Hou,Shijia Mei
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/s24196323
IF: 3.9
2024-09-30
Sensors
Abstract:Soil dielectric sensors have been widely used to obtain real-time soil moisture data, which are important for water resource management. However, soluble salts in the soil significantly affect the accuracy of these sensor measurements. Therefore, it is crucial to select suitable soil dielectric sensors for soil moisture measurements at different salinity levels. Eight mainstream sensors (EC-5, 5TE, Teros12, Hydra-probe II, TDR315L, TDR315H, TDR305H, and CS655) were selected and tested at four different soil salinity levels (EC1:5 = 3.0, 1.5, 1.0, and 0.75 dS·m−1). The measured values using the factory calibration formulas were compared at six soil moisture levels. The results showed that the measured soil moisture values from various sensors exhibited varying degrees of overestimation, which increased with increasing salinity. Only EC-5 did not exhibit distortion at high-salinity levels, with the measured values showing a good linear trend compared to the standard values. Mutational distortion of the measured apparent dielectric permittivity occurred in TDR315L, TDR315H, Hydra-probe II, and 5TE at EC1:5 = 3.0 dS·m−1. Insensitive distortion of the measured apparent dielectric permittivity occurred in Teros12 and TDR305H at EC1:5 = 3.0 dS·m−1 as well as in Teros12, TDR305H, 5TE and Hydra-probe II at EC1:5 = 1.5 dS·m−1. All tested sensors performed reasonably well at EC1:5 ≤ 1.0 dS·m−1. Seven sensors (excluding CS655) were calibrated within the distortion threshold. The soil moisture accuracy using the calibrated formulas could reach ±0.02 cm3·cm−3. At EC1:5 ≤ 1.0 dS·m−1, most sensors in this study could be applied with the factory calibration formulas. TDR series, EC-5, 5TE and Teros12 were recommended after calibration for EC1:5 > 1.0 dS·m−1. For extremely high soil salinity levels, the TDR series and EC-5 may be the best choices.
engineering, electrical & electronic,chemistry, analytical,instruments & instrumentation