A Novel Experimental Approach to Identifying the Cognitive Mechanisms Underlying Loneliness

Dino Zagic,Ronald M. Rapee,Viviana M. Wuthrich

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10608-024-10494-w

2024-05-30

Cognitive Therapy and Research

Abstract:Current models of loneliness emphasise the role of maladaptive cognitions in causing and/or maintaining loneliness. However, standardised paradigms to experimentally examine the role of maladaptive cognition in loneliness are lacking, making it difficult to establish causality. This paper tested a mock online chat paradigm designed to induce changes in negative affect (loneliness, depression, and anxiety), and strength of belief in lonely thoughts, by manipulating comparative and normative fit.

psychology, clinical

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is the lack of standardized experimental paradigms to verify the causal relationships in current cognitive models of loneliness. Specifically, existing research mainly relies on correlational studies, which cannot definitively prove the causal role of these cognitive biases (such as biases in attention, interpretation, and memory) in maintaining loneliness. Therefore, the authors designed a new experimental method—a simulated online chat paradigm—to induce or reduce loneliness by manipulating comparative adaptability and normative adaptability, thereby verifying the role of these cognitive mechanisms in the formation and maintenance of loneliness.

### Main Objectives of the Paper:
1. **Design and test a new experimental paradigm**: By simulating online chats, manipulate participants' sense of social identity (i.e., comparative adaptability and normative adaptability) to induce or reduce loneliness.
2. **Verify the role of cognitive biases**: Measure the change in the strength of beliefs about loneliness before and after induction through the experimental paradigm to verify the causal role of cognitive biases in loneliness.
3. **Provide causal evidence**: Provide experimental evidence for existing cognitive models of loneliness (such as the model proposed by Cacioppo and Hawkley) to support the cognitive mechanisms proposed in these models.

### Experimental Method:
- **Participants**: 60 undergraduate psychology students from Macquarie University, Australia.
- **Experimental Conditions**: Participants were randomly assigned to one of two groups:
- **Loneliness Induction Group**: First, a loneliness induction chat, followed by a social connection induction chat.
- **Social Connection Induction Group**: Two social connection induction chats.
- **Measurement Indicators**: Including loneliness, depression, anxiety, and the strength of beliefs about loneliness.

### Experimental Results:
- **Loneliness Induction**: Successfully increased participants' loneliness, but had no significant effect on the strength of beliefs about loneliness.
- **Social Connection Induction**: Significantly reduced participants' overall negative emotions, with effects accumulating over multiple chats.

### Conclusion:
The experimental paradigm, by manipulating comparative adaptability and normative adaptability, can effectively increase loneliness or reduce overall negative emotions. This method provides a new tool for verifying the causal relationships in cognitive models of loneliness.