Assessing early feasibility of a novel innovation to increase consumer partnership capability within an Australian health innovation organisation using a mixed-method approach

Liz Newton,Tara Louise Dimopoulos-Bick
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2023-080495
IF: 3.006
2024-05-02
BMJ Open
Abstract:Objective Engagement-capable health organisations recognise that consumer engagement (also known as patient engagement, consumer engagement, patient and public involvement) must occur at every level of the organisation if it is to be meaningful and genuine. Despite this aspiration, health organisations struggle to adopt, implement, and embody consumer engagement capability in a way that has yielded impact. The Partner Ring (PR) is an embedded model for building staff capability for consumer partnerships. It is hosted by an employed Patient Partner. PR was implemented at the Agency for Clinical Innovation in New South Wales, Australia. The aim of this study was to assess the feasibility (acceptability, demand and practicality) of this innovation to increase consumer engagement capability. Design One-group post-intervention mixed methods approach to assess feasibility. Participants ACI staff engaged in the PR (n=40 of 89 members). Data collection and analysis Qualitative data was collected through an artificial intelligence (AI)-driven interactive interview, with 40 responses received between 29 June and 12 July 2023. A framework analysis and Generative AI causal mapping were conducted to identify and visualise causal claims within the texts. Cost and session attendance collected from the same point in time supplemented the analysis. Findings Findings were categorised by the following feasibility constructs: acceptability, demand and practicality. Almost all the respondents indicated their intent to continue using the PR and outlined personal benefits and professional benefits. For example, (n=23, 57%) reacted positively to the psychological safety of the PR, and professionally people identified attendance increased their knowledge and skills (n=23, 57%). Conclusion The PR is feasible and likely to be an acceptable innovation for building staff capability and consumer engagement skills across a large health system or organisation. It could be adopted or adapted by other jurisdictions.
medicine, general & internal
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily explores a novel innovation model called "Partner Ring (PR)" aimed at enhancing consumer collaboration capabilities within a health innovation organization in Australia. The study evaluates the feasibility of this innovation model in its early stages through a mixed-methods approach, focusing on its acceptability, demand, and practicality. ### Research Objectives The main objective of the paper is to assess the feasibility of PR as an innovation model in enhancing consumer engagement capabilities. Specifically, the study focuses on the following three aspects: 1. **Acceptability**: Is PR accepted by the organization's staff? 2. **Demand**: To what extent is PR utilized by the organization's staff? 3. **Practicality**: Does PR have a positive or negative impact on the organization's staff? What challenges or facilitating factors were encountered during its implementation? ### Research Design and Participants - **Design**: A post-intervention mixed-methods research design was employed. - **Participants**: A total of 40 staff members from the Agency for Clinical Innovation (ACI) in New South Wales participated in the study. These staff members were active members of PR and committed to engaging in consumer collaboration activities. ### Key Findings - **Demand**: Approximately 30% of ACI staff registered for PR, with 89% having attended at least one meeting. Almost all respondents (97.5%) expressed their intention to continue participating in PR. - **Acceptability**: All respondents gave positive feedback on PR, particularly regarding the psychological safety it provided and the enhancement of personal and professional skills. Additionally, PR improved staff job satisfaction. - **Practicality**: PR was considered beneficial, offering personal and professional advantages, including increased confidence and personal development. From a cost perspective, the administrative expenses for implementing PR totaled approximately AUD 14,080 during the study period. In summary, PR, as an innovative model to enhance staff consumer collaboration capabilities, demonstrated high feasibility in its initial implementation phase. It can potentially be adopted or adapted in broader health systems or organizations in the future.