Abstract:BackgroundThe avian family Cettiidae, including the genera Cettia, Urosphena, Tesia, Abroscopus and Tickellia and Orthotomus cucullatus, has recently been proposed based on analysis of a small number of loci and species. The close relationship of most of these taxa was unexpected, and called for a comprehensive study based on multiple loci and dense taxon sampling. In the present study, we infer the relationships of all except one of the species in this family using one mitochondrial and three nuclear loci. We use traditional gene tree methods (Bayesian inference, maximum likelihood bootstrapping, parsimony bootstrapping), as well as a recently developed Bayesian species tree approach (*BEAST) that accounts for lineage sorting processes that might produce discordance between gene trees. We also analyse mitochondrial DNA for a larger sample, comprising multiple individuals and a large number of subspecies of polytypic species.ResultsThere are many topological incongruences among the single-locus trees, although none of these is strongly supported. The multi-locus tree inferred using concatenated sequences and the species tree agree well with each other, and are overall well resolved and well supported by the data. The main discrepancy between these trees concerns the most basal split. Both methods infer the genus Cettia to be highly non-monophyletic, as it is scattered across the entire family tree. Deep intraspecific divergences are revealed, and one or two species and one subspecies are inferred to be non-monophyletic (differences between methods).ConclusionsThe molecular phylogeny presented here is strongly inconsistent with the traditional, morphology-based classification. The remarkably high degree of non-monophyly in the genus Cettia is likely to be one of the most extraordinary examples of misconceived relationships in an avian genus. The phylogeny suggests instances of parallel evolution, as well as highly unequal rates of morphological divergence in different lineages. This complex morphological evolution apparently misled earlier taxonomists. These results underscore the well-known but still often neglected problem of basing classifications on overall morphological similarity. Based on the molecular data, a revised taxonomy is proposed. Although the traditional and species tree methods inferred much the same tree in the present study, the assumption by species tree methods that all species are monophyletic is a limitation in these methods, as some currently recognized species might have more complex histories.

A new perspective on the taxonomy and systematics of Arvicolinae (Gray, 1821) and a new time-calibrated phylogeny for the clade

Congruence, fossils and the evolutionary tree of rodents and lagomorphs

Taxonomic position of Chinese voles of the tribe Arvicolini and the description of 2 new species from Xizang, China

Evolution of the skull in arvicoline cricetids (Rodentia) according to 3D morphometric insights: Part 1. Morphological disparity of the palato-spheno-pterygoid complex

Evolution of the Rodents: Phylogeny and evolutionary history of hystricognathous rodents from the Old World during the Tertiary: new insights into the emergence of modern “phiomorph” families

Molecular phylogeny and trait evolution in an ancient terrestrial arthropod lineage: Systematic revision and implications for ecological divergence (Collembola, Tomocerinae) (vol 154, 106995, 2021)

Reassessment of the Taxonomic Status of Craseomys and Three Controversial Species of Myodes and Alticola (rodentia: Arvicolinae).

Non-monophyly and intricate morphological evolution within the avian family Cettiidae revealed by multilocus analysis of a taxonomically densely sampled dataset

Redescription of a small Caviidae (Rodentia: Hystricognathi) from the Neogene of northwestern Argentina and its systematic implications

Molecular estimation of eulipotyphlan divergence times and the evolution of "Insectivora"

Corrected placement of Mus-Rattus fossil calibration forces precision in the molecular tree of rodents

Molecular phylogeny and taxonomy of the genus Vernaya (Mammalia: Rodentia: Muridae) with the description of two new species

Complete Mitochondrial Genome of a New Voleproedromys Liangshanensis(rodentia: Cricetidae) and Phylogenetic Analysis with Related Species: Are There Implications for the Validity of the Genusproedromys?

Molecular Phylogeny and Trait Evolution in an Ancient Terrestrial Arthropod Lineage: Systematic Revision and Implications for Ecological Divergence (collembola, Tomocerinae)

An Estimation of Erinaceidae Phylogeny: A Combined Analysis Approach

Molecular time estimates for the Lagomorpha diversification

A Species-Level Phylogeny of Old World Fruit Bats with a New Higher-Level Classification of the Family Pteropodidae

Unraveling the Myotis morass: ultraconserved-element analysis reveals introgression, cryptic diversity, and taxonomic trouble

Inferring phylogenetic relationships in the common vole (Microtus arvalis) based on mitochondrial and nuclear sequence diversities

Whole-genome-based phylogenetic analyses provide new insights into the evolution of springtails (Hexapoda: Collembola)

A Multi-Locus Phylogeny of Nectogalini Shrews and Influences of the Paleoclimate on Speciation and Evolution.