Abstract:Community engagement and involvement has been increasingly recognized as an ethical and valuable component of health science research over the past two decades. Progress in the engagement field has been accompanied by emerging standards that emphasise participation, two-way communication, inclusion, empowerment, and ownership. Although these are important and noble benchmarks, they can represent a challenge for research conducted in marginalized contexts. This community case study reports on the methods, outcomes, constraints and learning from a community engagement project called Bucket Loads of Health, implemented in the Western Cape province of South Africa. The project approach involved using multiple participatory visual methods to foster two-way communication between members of two disenfranchised communities, Enkanini and Delft, and a group of water microbiologists at Stellenbosch University who were conducting research in Enkanini. The project was carried out during the 2018 Western Cape water crisis, under the growing threat of 'Day Zero'. The resulting visual outputs illustrated the negative impacts of water shortage on health and wellbeing in these community settings and showcased scientific endeavours seeking to address them. Engagement included knowledge exchange combining body maps, role play performances and films created by the community members, with hand maps, posters and presentations produced by the scientists. Whereas these engagement tools enabled reciprocal listening between all groups, their ability to respond to the issues raised was hindered by constraints in resources and capacity beyond their control. An additional core objective of the project was to bring the impacts of water shortage in participating communities, and the work of the research team, to the attention of local government. The case study demonstrates the challenges that politically ambitious community engagement faces in being acknowledged by government representatives. We further the argument that research institutions and funders need to match professed commitments to engagement with training and resources to support researchers and community members in responding to the needs and aspirations surfaced through engagement processes. We introduce the concept of engagement integrity to capture the gap between recommended standards of community engagement and what is realistically achievable in projects that are constrained by funding, time, and political interest.

Bringing river health into being with citizen science: River commons co-learning and practice

Progressing from Science Communication to Engagement: Community Voices on Water Quality and Access in Makhanda

GC Insights: Lessons from participatory water quality research in the upper Santa River basin, Peru

Steps Toward Engagement Integrity: Learning From Participatory Visual Methods in Marginalized South African Communities

Collaborating With Communities: Citizen Science Flood Monitoring in Urban Informal Settlements

Protecting and restoring freshwater biodiversity across urban areas in Aotearoa New Zealand: Citizens' reporting of pollution in stormwater drains and waterways

Citizen Science and Natural Resource Management: A Social Network Analysis of Two Community-Based Water Monitoring Programs

Unravelling and understanding local perceptions of water quality in the Santa basin, Peru

Practicalities of community-led continuous water quality monitoring: lessons from Taiwan and UK pilots

Citizen science for hydrological risk reduction and resilience building

Can citizen science inform science? Evaluating the results of the Bellingen Riverwatch citizen science program and a complimentary government monitoring program

For environmental monitors, relationships matter in multiple ways: insights from a research collaboration in South Africa

The benefits and negative impacts of citizen science applications to water as experienced by participants and communities

Human–River Relationships

Advancing freshwater science with sensor data collected by community scientists

Designing citizen science for water and ecosystem services management in data-poor regions: Challenges and opportunities

A transdisciplinary approach supports community-led water quality monitoring in river basins adjacent to the Great Barrier Reef, Australia

Internet of Things and citizen science as alternative water quality monitoring approaches and the importance of effective water quality communication

Sensing, knowing, and making water quality along Marikina River in the Philippines

Ecological Public Health and Participatory Planning and Assessment Dilemmas: The Case of Water Resources Management

Community values on governing urban water nature-based solutions in Sydney, Australia