Microbroth dilution method for antibiotic susceptibility testing of fastidious and anaerobic bacteria of the urinary microbiome

Wilson Geaman,Brian I. Choi,Jacob Kaindl,Caroline Gonzalez,Alan J. Wolfe
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1128/spectrum.00314-24
IF: 3.7
2024-05-07
Microbiology Spectrum
Abstract:ABSTRACT Bacterial isolates from the human urinary microbiome have been extensively studied for their antibiotic resistance; however, little work has been done on those isolates that are difficult to grow in vitro . This study was designed to qualify a serum-based medium, New York City Broth III (NYCIII), in both sections =and a broth microdilution method to determine the antibiotic susceptibility of previously underreported or undescribed microbes that have a difficult time growing in standard Mueller-Hinton broth. Here, we demonstrate that NYCIII microbroth dilution can be an effective method for the determination of antibiotic susceptibility of species found in the human urinary microbiome. We show that this method serves well to characterize fastidious and anaerobic urinary microbes that have no Clinical and Laboratory Standards Institute (CLSI) guidelines, including several in the families Aerococcaceae , Lactobacillaceae , or Actinomycetaceae . Previous studies using expanded quantitative urine culture reveal that urine samples from clinical patients are commonly polymicrobial in composition. Thus, we test whether NYCIII can serve as a viable harmonized medium, capable of supporting antibiotic susceptibility testing in a range of fastidious, non-fastidious, and anaerobic urinary microbes. We propose this methodology to be standardized comparable to CLSI standards to allow for resistance testing in uncharacterized urinary bacteria. IMPORTANCE Antibiotic susceptibilities of fastidious and anaerobic bacteria of the human urinary microbiome are largely underreported due to difficulty in growing them in the lab environment. The current standard medium, Muller-Hinton broth, has difficulty supporting the growth of many of these species, leaving microbiologists without a standardized method. To address this need, this study offers a methodology to survey susceptibilities in a high-throughput manner of these understudied microbes with a proposed harmonized medium, NYCIII, which is capable of supporting the growth of both fastidious and non-fastidious urinary microbes. Broader standardization of this method can allow for the development of antibiotic-resistant breakpoints of the many uncharacterized urinary microbes.
microbiology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problems does this paper attempt to solve? This paper aims to solve the problem of antibiotic susceptibility testing (AST) for fastidious and anaerobic bacteria in the human urethral microbiota that are difficult to culture in vitro. Specifically, standard culture media such as Mueller - Hinton broth (MHB) cannot effectively support the growth of these microorganisms, resulting in a serious lack of antibiotic susceptibility data for these species. #### Main problems: 1. **Difficult - to - culture microorganisms**: Many urethral microorganisms, especially fastidious and anaerobic bacteria, are difficult to culture in the laboratory environment, which makes their antibiotic susceptibility testing very difficult. 2. **Lack of standardized methods**: Currently, there are no standardized AST methods for these difficult - to - culture microorganisms, leading to a lack of guidance for clinicians during treatment and the possible over - use or misuse of antibiotics. 3. **Limitations of existing culture media**: The commonly used Mueller - Hinton broth (MHB) supplemented with lysed - horse - blood serum (CAMHB - LHB) can promote the growth of some fastidious bacteria, but its opacity hinders the ability to measure bacterial growth by optical density. #### Solutions: To overcome these problems, the researchers proposed a new culture medium - New York City Broth III (NYCIII). NYCIII has the following advantages: - **Transparency**: Using horse serum instead of lysed - horse - blood maintains the transparency of the culture medium, allowing the monitoring of bacterial growth by optical density measurement. - **Broad - spectrum applicability**: It can support the growth of a variety of fastidious and non - fastidious bacteria, including some urethral microorganisms that have not been fully studied. - **High - throughput screening**: It can be carried out in a 96 - well plate format, facilitating the rapid screening of a large number of samples. By validating the application of NYCIII in AST, the researchers hope to establish standardized AST guidelines for these under - studied urethral microorganisms, thereby improving the accuracy and effectiveness of clinical treatment. #### Research objectives: - To verify the effectiveness of NYCIII as an AST culture medium. - To determine whether NYCIII can support the growth of a variety of urethral microorganisms and provide reliable AST results. - To promote the standardization of NYCIII and make it a universal method for evaluating the antibiotic susceptibility of emerging urinary tract pathogens. Through these efforts, the researchers hope to fill the current gap in antibiotic susceptibility data for urethral microorganisms, improve clinical treatment decisions, and reduce the risk of antibiotic abuse.