Diverse migration patterns of anadromous white-spotted charr Salvelinus leucomaenis revealed from otolith microchemistry

Akihiko Goto,Mari Kuroki,Kotaro Shirai,Kentaro Morita
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10228-023-00943-z
2024-01-23
Ichthyological Research
Abstract:Anadromous migration of salmonid fish has been extensively studied, primarily focusing on the dichotomous framework of anadromy and residency. However, there remains a limited understanding of intermediate migratory behaviors within the anadromous framework. Our study aimed to classify the lifetime migration patterns of the anadromous white-spotted charr Salvelinus leucomaenis within and among populations using otolith annuli and Sr:Ca ratios. Initially, the migratory histories of anadromous charr were divided into two stages: "virgin sea-run stage" and "veteran sea-run stage". The former was further categorized into three types: ocean entry at age ≥1+ years old, early descending, and brackish use. The latter was grouped into four types: annual migrants, frequent migrants, retired migrants, and ocean residents. We found that the proportion of migration patterns varied among rivers, with multiple patterns coexisting within the same river. Migration patterns typically involving 1–5 years spent in freshwater rivers followed by annual oceanic migrations were the most abundant, although diverse patterns were also observed. In the virgin sea-run stage, some individuals experienced the ocean at age 0+ years or brackish environments before their first sea entry. In the veteran sea-run stage, we found individuals who had resided in either the ocean or rivers for over a year. Retired migrants, characterized by stopping oceanic migration at a certain age and subsequently spending time in rivers, were exclusive to southern rivers. Conversely, ocean residents who spend one or more years in the ocean were more frequent in northern regions. Consequently, the lifetime migration patterns of anadromous white-spotted charr may exhibit stronger ocean dependency at higher latitudes. The implications of this study highlight the complexity and flexibility of migratory behaviors within and among white-spotted charr populations.
zoology,marine & freshwater biology,fisheries
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore and classify the diverse migration patterns of white - spotted char ( *Salvelinus leucomaenis* ) in multiple rivers in Hokkaido and Honshu, Japan during their life cycles, and to discuss the distribution trends of these patterns in different geographical locations. Specifically, the researchers hypothesized that in higher - latitude areas, ocean - dependent migration patterns would occur more frequently. By analyzing the micro - chemical composition of fish otoliths, especially the strontium - to - calcium ratio (Sr:Ca ratio), the researchers hope to reveal the complex migratory behaviors of white - spotted char and how these behaviors change with geographical regions. ### Research Background and Problems The anadromous migration behavior of salmonids has been widely studied, mainly within the binary framework of anadromy and residency. However, the understanding of intermediate migratory behaviors within the anadromous framework remains limited. This study aims to classify the life - cycle migration patterns of white - spotted char through otolith annuli and Sr:Ca ratio, and to explore the differences in these patterns among different populations. ### Research Objectives 1. **Classify Life - Cycle Migration Patterns**: Use otolith microchemical analysis methods to classify the life - cycle migration patterns of white - spotted char. 2. **Geographical Trend Analysis**: Explore whether there are differences in the migration patterns of white - spotted char in different geographical locations, especially whether they are more ocean - dependent in high - latitude areas. ### Methods - **Sample Collection**: Collect white - spotted char samples from 16 rivers in Hokkaido and Honshu, Japan. - **Otolith Analysis**: Determine the age and migration history of fish through otolith annuli and Sr:Ca ratio (Sr:Ca ratio). - **Migration Pattern Classification**: Divide the migration history into two stages: the virgin sea - run stage and the veteran sea - run stage, and further subdivide them into different types. - **Statistical Analysis**: Use the generalized linear mixed model (GLMM) to analyze biological characteristics (such as body length, age, condition factor, etc.) under different migration patterns. ### Results - **Diversity of Migration Patterns**: The study found that there are at least 10 different life - cycle migration patterns in white - spotted char. - **Main Patterns**: The most common pattern is "normal - annual migrants", accounting for 66.8%. The second is "brackish use - annual migrants", accounting for 14.5%. - **Geographical Distribution Trends**: There are significant differences in the composition of migration patterns in different rivers. Individuals in high - latitude areas are more likely to be ocean residents, while individuals in low - latitude areas are more likely to be retired migrants. ### Discussion This study reveals the complex migratory behavior of white - spotted char and its geographical distribution trends. These findings not only enrich our understanding of the migratory behavior of salmonids but also provide important scientific basis for the protection and management of these species. In particular, the research results indicate that white - spotted char in different geographical regions may have different ecological requirements and adaptation strategies, which provide an important reference for formulating targeted conservation measures. ### Formula - **Estimation formula for fork length at first entry into the sea**: \[ L_{\text{fse}} = L_T+\frac{(O_{\text{fse}} - O_T)}{(O_T - O_0)}\times(L_T - L_0) \] where: - \( L_{\text{fse}} \): Fork length at first entry into the sea - \( L_T \): Fork length at capture - \( O_{\text{fse}} \): Otolith radius at the first high Sr:Ca ratio - \( O_T \): Otolith radius at capture - \( O_0 \): Otolith radius at larval emergence - \( L_0 \): Fork length at larval emergence Through these studies, we can better understand the migratory behavior of white - spotted char, thereby providing scientific support for the protection of this species.