Bus bunching: a comprehensive review from demand, supply, and decision-making perspectives

Mustafa RezazadaNeema NassirEgemen TaninAvishai (Avi) Cedera Faculty of Engineering and Information Technology,University of Melbourne,Parkville,Australiab Faculty of Civil and Environmental Engineering,Technion-Israel Institute of Technology,Haifa,Israel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/01441647.2024.2313969

IF: 10.185

2024-02-09

Transport Reviews

Abstract:Public transport service reliability is crucial for all stakeholders, including users, operators, and society. Bus bunching, where two or more buses on the same route travel closely together, significantly undermines service reliability. This paper reviews bus bunching, its causes and consequences, and control strategies from demand, supply, and decision-making perspectives. It identifies gaps in the literature, emphasising the need for realistic evaluations of control methods and real-world applications. The paper reveals that most bunching solutions prioritise operators over public transport users, and the trade-offs posed by these methods require further examinations. Hybrid methods combining holding with other measures have outperformed standalone holding methods but need real-world testing. User-centric approaches, such as encouraging and incentivising passengers to choose less crowded vehicles or wait, have demonstrated some potential in alleviating service bunching. However, their effectiveness in real-world applications present important research directions. In summary, the practical classification and framework presented in this review can assist policymakers in making informed and optimised decisions by considering various variables and performance measures involved in the process, and in finding balanced solutions for passenger and operator.

transportation

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily addresses the issue of bus bunching, a phenomenon where two or more buses closely follow each other on the same route, which can severely impact the reliability of public transportation services.

Specifically, the paper provides a comprehensive review of bus bunching from the perspectives of demand, supply, and decision-making. It analyzes the causes, consequences, and control strategies of bus bunching and identifies gaps in the existing literature. The paper emphasizes the importance of considering real-world conditions when evaluating control methods and points out that most solutions to the bunching problem tend to focus on operators rather than passengers, with the trade-offs of these methods warranting further study. Additionally, hybrid methods that combine holding with other measures perform better than single holding methods but still need to be tested in practical applications. User-centered approaches, such as encouraging passengers to choose less crowded vehicles or wait, have shown some potential, but their effectiveness in real-world applications remains an important research direction.

Finally, the paper proposes a practical classification framework aimed at helping policymakers make informed and optimized decisions by considering the various variables and performance indicators involved in the process, seeking balanced solutions between passengers and operators.