Abstract:Introduction: Donor nephrectomy (DN) is a unique surgical procedure in urological practice, as it involves exposing a healthy individual to the potential risks of surgery. This type of surgery exhibits heterogeneity in terms of approach (open, laparoscopic, or robotic), each with its unique set of advantages and disadvantages. Consequently, there is currently a lack of universally agreed upon clear guidelines. In these settings, this study aims to evaluate transplantation surgeons' knowledge through a real-life survey and compare it with data from published randomized controlled trials (RCTs). Evidence acquisition: The study is divided into two parts, with the first part focusing on the outcomes of the real-life survey designed to assess surgeons' knowledge about different DN approaches and their real-world practices during the surgery. The second part involves a systematic review and meta-analysis of RCTs, specifically examining the outcomes of different surgical approaches to DN. The systematic review followed the PRISMA Guidelines and involved a search of PubMed and Web of Science for RCTs comparing the outcomes of different DN approaches. The risk of bias was assessed using the RoB-2 tool. The random effect model was mainly used to assess the mean difference of the included studies. Evidence synthesis: The study was conducted between July 2021 and January 2022 and surveyed 50 surgeons, of which 35 participants (70%) completed the survey. Regarding various approaches to DN, 97.14% of surgeons reported having experience with live DN, and 45.72% performed over 15 cases per year. The most performed approach was pure laparoscopic DN (68.57%). Pure laparoscopic DN was the preferred approach for 77.42% of respondents. The review process resulted in 335 articles, of which 35 were eligible for inclusion in the systematic review. In summary, most studies found that laparoscopic approaches, including standard, hand-assisted, LESS-DN, and mini-LDN, resulted in less postoperative pain, better cosmetic, and quicker recovery times compared to open approaches. The main limitation of the current study is the heterogeneity of the included studies. Conclusions: The study provides valuable insights into the practices of renal transplantation surgeons, offering a comprehensive comparison to level 1 studies (RCTs) in the field. It underscores the continued significance of ODN in contemporary practice, particularly in light of recommendations from the EAU guidelines on renal transplantation. This reaffirms the need to consider the advantages and disadvantages of various approaches, including factors such as cost, postoperative pain, and cosmetic outcomes. While robotic-assisted DN holds promise, their adoption remains variable, potentially due to limited robust evidence.

Transplant nephrectomy: indication, surgical approach and complications—experiences from a single transplantation center

Impact of Renal Allograft Nephrectomy on Graft and Patient Survival Following Retransplantation: a Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Transplant Nephrectomy: A Comparative Study of Timing and Techniques in a Single Institution

Transplant papers of high impact published in the year 2019 in NDT

Surgical Complications after Kidney Transplantation: Different Impacts of Immunosuppression, Graft Function, Patient Variables, and Surgical Performance

Clinical Analysis of 2520 Renal Transplantations in One Center

Management of Failing Kidney and Pancreas Transplantations

Retroperitoneal Laparoscopic Nephrectomy Combined with Bench Surgery and Autotransplantation for Renal Cell Carcinoma in the Solitary Kidney or Tumor Involving Bilateral Kidneys: Experience at a Single Center and Technical Considerations.

Long-term Kidney Transplant Survival Across the Globe

Kidney re-transplantation in the ipsilateral iliac fossa: a surgeon's perspective on perioperative outcome

Robotic Assisted Transplant Nephrectomy: Case Series and Training Model for Improving Adoption

Impact of early surgical complications on kidney transplant outcomes

Optimizing the kidney donor pool: transplanting donor kidneys after partial nephrectomy of masses or cysts

Urologists' proficiency in various donor nephrectomy approaches: a real-life survey, systematic review, and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials

[Transplant Candidate with Cancer: Should We Proceed?]

Surgical modifications to the conventional kidney transplant technique - the miami transplant institute approach: a retrospective cohort study

Recent Developments in Kidney Transplantation-A Critical Assessment

[Retrospective Study of Dysfunction Transplant Nephrectomy from a Single-Center Within 10 Years].

Cadaver Renal Transplantation and Multivariate Analysis for Graft Survival: a Clinical Review of 2 016 Cases

Retroperitoneoscopic Live-donor Right Nephrectomy: A Chinese Single Center

Influence of Surgical Complications on Outcomes in Kidney Transplantation Patients