Assessing the Effect of a Technology-Based Peer-Mentoring Intervention on Renal Teams' Perceived Knowledge and Comfort Level Working with Young Adults on Dialysis.
Erica E Perry,Kai Zheng,Andrew Grogan-Kaylor,Mark W Newman,Tiffany C E Veinot
2010-01-01
Abstract:Young adults (YAs) between ages 20 and 30 account for only 2.7% of patients on all forms of dialysis in the United States, as the average age of dialysis onset is 65 (U.S. Renal Data System, 2009). While small in number, provision of care to YAs on dialysis presents significant challenges to renal teams. How is the experience of chronic kidney disease (CKD) different for a 20 year old, as opposed to that of a 65-year-old retiree? As compared with older adults, YAs with CKD experience unique psychosocial hardships because their life course is less defined, and their adult identities have not yet emerged. The demands of kidney disease and its treatment not only pull young adults away from their usual social lives, but they also derail them from their developmental trajectories of individuation, maturation and independence (Ferris, Gipson, Kimmel, & Eggers, 2006). With an undermined self-concept and self-image, YAs with CKD often develop psychological defenses that may manifest as anger, depression and withdrawal, as well as uncommunicative and unapproachable interactions with their renal teams (Bell, 2007). Furthermore, their perceptions of the disease and the consequences of treatment non-adherence are not based on potential health risks; rather, they relate to the ways in which treatment interferes with school, recreation and daily routines, and the ways in which their peers react to their illness (Harwood & Johnson, 1999). As a result, YAs with CKD are less likely to adhere to treatment, thus increasing their morbidity and mortality risks (Saran et al., 2003; Smith & Shuchman, 2005). The long-term kidney transplant outcomes of YAs, for example, are considerably poorer than those in older age groups (Rianthavorn & Ettenger, 2005). A recent report issued to Congress describes that while young adults with CKD have the most successful 1-year kidney transplant survival rates, they also have the worst 5-year graft survival rates largely due to non-adherence to kidney transplant medications. This report also describes the significant financial impact on society and advocates for innovative interventions (U.S. Government Accountability Office, 2007). Unfortunately, there is a paucity of nephrology research regarding potential intervention strategies to help patients in this age group (Jennette & Ferris, 2006). In a few studies focused on pediatric and adolescent patients, researchers have shown that psychosocial services, as compared to traditional psychotherapy, could achieve better results (Dittman, Hesse, & Wallis, 1984; Jarzembowski et al., 2004); for example, increasing staff support time for pediatric patients after kidney transplantation leads to improved preventive care outcomes (Jarzembowski et al., 2004). Additionally, during YAs’ transition from pediatric to adult programs, it is recommended that they receive open communication and be given choices by their peers, families and trusted renal team staff (Watson & Shooter, 1996). This transition clearly triggers a cultural shift from a child-centered milieu—where parents have had major input—to an adult unit where the late adolescent and YA needs to increasingly engage in autonomous decision making (Watson & Shooter, 1996). Peer mentoring—training selected patients to listen to, empathize with, role model for and empower other patients—has been demonstrated to be an effective approach to enhancing communication and providing patients with opportunities for informed choice (Kapron, Perry, Bowman, & Swartz, 1997; Heisler & Piette, 2005). The National Kidney Foundation of Michigan (NKFM) has experienced significant success with an adult-focused peer mentoring program; indeed, it has been shown to alleviate patients’ fears about the disease and to help patients cope with dialysis and life after a kidney transplant (Wright, 2000). Additionally, in a randomized trial, this program was shown to increase CKD patients’ rates of advance directive completion and to increase their comfort in discussing their wishes with their renal team (Perry et al., 2005). However, there are important challenges in extending the benefits of peer mentoring to YAs on dialysis. Because YAs constitute such a small portion of the patient population with kidney failure, many dialysis units lack access to appropriate peer mentors to advise patients in this age group. In this research, we developed and tested a technology-enabled peer-mentoring program to support YAs on dialysis and their renal teams. This article, as part of a larger project evaluating the program’s effectiveness, presents our findings on how it affected renal teams’ perceived knowledge regarding the disease’s impact on YAs; perceptions of YA adherence and comfort talking with the team; and staff comfort levels in working with YA patients. We were interested in studying renal team staff because, first, we suspected that much of renal teams’ frustration in working with YAs on dialysis is due to the fact that they have not focused on YAs’ unique challenges and care needs because they are such a small portion of their patient population. Second, we believed that if renal team members could better serve YAs, this would in turn result in improved psychosocial and health outcomes for YAs. Therefore, we created two DVDs of interviews: one with YA peer mentors and one with renal staff who have abundant experience working with dialysis patients in this age group. The YA DVD included young men and women, both African American and Caucasian, discussing how CKD and renal failure affected their lives in terms of relationships, insurance, body image, sexuality, education and careers. It also discussed their experiences in communicating with renal staff. The renal team DVD included an experienced team of nephrologists, nurses, social workers, dietitians and a physician assistant discussing the uniqueness of YAs on dialysis and effective approaches to working with them. Finally, based on extensive consultation with NKFM staff and peer mentors, we developed an online patient community website, ktalk.org. This website allows YAs on dialysis to anonymously interact with the YAs featured in the DVD, who acted as peer mentors on the website, as well as other YA patients who joined the community.