Determination of subsidy and emission control coverage under competition and cooperation of China-Europe Railway Express and liner shipping

Xu Gong,Zhi-Chun Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tranpol.2022.06.011

IF: 6.173

2022-09-01

Transport Policy

Abstract:Silk Road Economic Belt (SREB) and Maritime Silk Road (MSR) provide important avenues for cargo transport between China and Europe. This paper addresses the issues of the subsidy for China-Europe Railway Express (CERE) on the SREB and the sulfur emission control for liner shipping on the MSR from a perspective of building a community of shared future for mankind. Two welfare maximization models are proposed for determining the optimal subsidy and the optimal sulfur emission control coverage within which the sulfur in ships’ fuel oil is required to be less than 0.1%. One considers the competition between two transport modes (CERE and liner shipping), in which their own net profit is maximized. The other concerns the cooperation between two modes, in which their total net profit is maximized. The properties of the two models are analytically explored and compared. The results show that intermodal competition outperforms intermodal cooperation in terms of social welfare, consumer surplus, and environmental pollution, though at the cost of carrier profit and total subsidy from the regulator. The regulator may efficiently control the adverse impacts of an increase in the fuel oil price or in the marginal cost of air pollution on the social welfare of the system through adjusting the CERE subsidy and the sulfur emission control coverage.

transportation,economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on two aspects:

1. **Optimization of subsidy policies for China - Europe Railway Express**: The paper explores how to determine the optimal subsidy policies for China - Europe Railway Express (CERE) to promote freight transportation on the Silk Road Economic Belt (SREB). As a fast but high - cost transportation mode, China - Europe Railway Express has developed rapidly with strong support from the Chinese government. However, the high transportation cost needs to be balanced by government subsidies, which has led to the research need for the effectiveness of subsidy policies.

2. **Optimization of the coverage of Sulfur Emission Control Areas (SECA)**: The paper also studies how to determine the optimal coverage of Sulfur Emission Control Areas (SECA), especially the necessity of using marine gas oil (MGO) in container ship transportation on the Maritime Silk Road (MSR). The Sulfur Emission Control Area policy aims to reduce pollutant emissions in ship transportation, but it will also increase transportation costs at the same time.

### Problem Background

- **Competition and Cooperation between China - Europe Railway Express and Sea Transportation**: China - Europe Railway Express and sea transportation are two main transportation modes connecting China and Europe. China - Europe Railway Express has a shorter transportation time but higher transportation costs; while sea transportation has a longer transportation time but lower transportation costs. These two transportation modes form a competitive and cooperative relationship on the Silk Road Economic Belt and the Maritime Silk Road.
- **Trade - off between Environment and Economy**: Although the Sulfur Emission Control Area policy helps to reduce environmental pollution, it will increase the cost of sea transportation. Therefore, how to find a balance between environmental protection and economic benefits is an important research topic.
- **Policy Interaction**: There is an interaction between the subsidy policy for China - Europe Railway Express and the Sulfur Emission Control Area policy. For example, when the government increases the subsidy for China - Europe Railway Express, it may lead to more goods shifting from sea transportation to railway transportation, thus reducing the coverage of Sulfur Emission Control Areas. And vice versa.

### Research Objectives

The paper proposes two welfare - maximization models, considering the competition and cooperation scenarios between China - Europe Railway Express and sea transportation respectively, aiming to determine the optimal subsidy for China - Europe Railway Express and the coverage of Sulfur Emission Control Areas to maximize social welfare. Specifically:

- **Competition Model**: In the competition model, China - Europe Railway Express companies and sea transportation companies each maximize their own net profits.
- **Cooperation Model**: In the cooperation model, the two companies jointly maximize the total net profit.

### Main Contributions

1. **Model Construction**: The paper constructs behavioral models describing China - Europe Railway Express companies and sea transportation companies in competition and cooperation scenarios, and analyzes the impacts of subsidy policies and sulfur emission control policies on freight rates and freight volumes.
2. **Determination of Optimal Strategies**: The paper also determines the optimal subsidy for China - Europe Railway Express and the coverage of Sulfur Emission Control Areas to maximize social welfare from the perspective of building a community with a shared future for mankind in competition or cooperation scenarios.

Through these studies, the paper provides theoretical basis and empirical support for the formulation of relevant policies, which is helpful to promote trade development between China and Europe while taking into account environmental protection and economic benefits.