Labor archetypes in industrial transitions: Case studies from yankee whaling and gulf wind energy in the United States

Jessica Staggs,Joshua A. Drew,L. Jen Shaffer
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.erss.2024.103535
IF: 8.514
2024-04-19
Energy Research & Social Science
Abstract:This paper uses the novel concept of labor archetypes to analyze two case studies of industrial transitions: the late 19th to early 20th century transition away from Yankee whaling in Massachusetts and the current transition toward wind energy along the Gulf Coast in the United States. We use a comparative, qualitative case study to examine transitions in four communities through review and synthesis of news articles. Labor archetypes are cultural archetypes created by imbuing a particular type of labor with cultural value, making that form of labor into an icon of a group of people. The reciprocal influence of labor archetypes and resilience is inductively explored using a resilience framework. The labor archetype of the Yankee whaler was used to defend historic modes of economic production in Massachusetts. In the Gulf South, the oil worker archetype reinforces views of a heritage to be defended tied closely to the oil industry. However, the archetype can be used to increase adaptive capacity, enhancing local resilience on the Gulf in the face of national pressure to decarbonize, by emphasizing that offshore wind energy maintains much of the local value of offshore oil work.
environmental studies
What problem does this paper attempt to address?