Advantages and Limitations of the Body Mass Index (BMI) to Assess Adult Obesity

Yilun Wu,Dan Li,Sten H. Vermund
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph21060757
IF: 4.614
2024-06-10
International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health
Abstract:Obesity reflects excessive fat deposits. At-risk individuals are guided by healthcare professionals to eat fewer calories and exercise more, often using body mass index (BMI; weight/height2) thresholds for screening and to guide progress and prognosis. By conducting a mini-narrative review of original articles, websites, editorials, commentaries, and guidelines, we sought to place BMI in the context of its appropriate use in population health, clinical screening, and monitoring in clinical care. The review covers studies and publications through 2023, encompassing consensus reviews and relevant literature. Recent consensus reviews suggest that BMI is a valuable tool for population surveys and primary healthcare screening but has limitations in predicting the risk of chronic diseases and assessing excess fat. BMI can guide nutritional and exercise counseling, even if it is inadequate for reliable individual risk prediction. BMI cut-offs must be reconsidered in populations of varying body build, age, and/or ethnicity. Since BMI-diagnosed overweight persons are sometimes physically and physiologically fit by other indicators, persons who are overweight on BMI should be more fully evaluated, diagnosed, and monitored with combined anthropometric and performance metrics to better clarify risks. The use of combined anthropometric and performance metrics involves integrating measurements of body composition with assessments of physical function and fitness to provide a more comprehensive evaluation of an individual's health and fitness status. Eligibility for bariatric surgery or semaglutide satiety/appetite-reduction medications should not be determined by BMI alone. Awareness of the advantages and limitations of using BMI as a tool to assess adult obesity can maximize its appropriate use in the context of population health and in rapid clinical screening and evaluation.
public, environmental & occupational health,environmental sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem this paper attempts to address is the evaluation of the advantages and limitations of Body Mass Index (BMI) in assessing adult obesity. Specifically, the authors explore the appropriate application of BMI in population health, clinical screening, and monitoring by reviewing original articles, websites, editorial reviews, review articles, and guidelines. The paper focuses on the following aspects: 1. **Advantages of BMI**: - Simple to measure, low cost, suitable for large-scale population surveys and primary medical screening. - Can be used as a guiding tool for nutrition and exercise counseling. - Has certain value in predicting the risk and prognosis of some chronic diseases. 2. **Limitations of BMI**: - Cannot accurately measure body fat distribution, especially abdominal fat, which is an important indicator of risks such as cardiovascular diseases. - BMI thresholds may not be applicable for individuals of different body types, ages, races, and genders. - Cannot reflect functional health and fitness status, potentially leading to misjudgment of individual risk. - Limited predictive ability in specific populations, such as the elderly and South Asians. 3. **Application of BMI in clinical and public health**: - It is recommended to combine other anthropometric and performance indicators, such as waist circumference, waist-to-hip ratio, and waist-to-height ratio, to obtain a more comprehensive health assessment. - Avoid relying solely on BMI to decide whether to undergo weight loss surgery or use appetite suppressant drugs (such as semaglutide). - Increase awareness of the advantages and limitations of BMI to use this tool more appropriately in population health and rapid clinical screening. In summary, this paper aims to provide more comprehensive guidance for clinicians and public health workers by comprehensively evaluating the advantages and limitations of BMI, so as to make more accurate decisions when assessing adult obesity.