Psilocybin Without Psychotherapy: A Cart Without a Horse?

Mitch Earleywine,Joseph De Leo,Dinesh Bhayana,Bhavya Rajanna,Karen Scott
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.ajp.20230572
IF: 17.7
2024-01-03
American Journal of Psychiatry
Abstract:T o the E ditor : Goodwin and colleagues' recent commentary (1) will likely generate spirited conversation, but also potential misunderstandings and concern. They assert that psychotherapy sessions inherent in psychedelic-assisted treatment might not be essential. They imply that relevant psychotherapeutic discussions occur during the subjective effects of the molecule, which is not the case with psilocybin trials. We understand their argument—brief psychoeducation and psychedelics administered in safe settings could create improvements without other support save a follow-up visit. Nevertheless, we also understand concerns about the ethics of an approach with no psychotherapy. Perhaps some depressed clients could improve with psilocybin without psychotherapy, especially with appropriate social support and previous experience. Only data can answer this question. A clinical trial could compare groups with and without extensive preparation and integration. If we can agree on a meaningful effect size (perhaps d =0.4–0.80), an appropriately powered trial would require at least 80–280 participants (2).
psychiatry
What problem does this paper attempt to address?