Abstract:Background/Context Despite problems with accountability systems under No Child Left Behind, the policy has been widely commended for exposing the depth and breadth of educational inequality in the United States. As states implement new accountability systems, there is growing concern that attention to achievement gaps and the performance of marginalized children has faded. Many approved accountability plans no longer report achievement by student subgroups or include subgroup performance in the calculation of accountability indicators. Research Purpose This study examined the informational significance of Oklahoma's A–F accountability grades relative to the policy objective of achievement equity. Informational significance as explained in self-determination theory provided a framework to explore the usefulness of an A–F grade for understanding achievement differences within and between schools. Research Design We evaluated the informational significance of Oklahoma A–F school grades by analyzing reading and math test scores from over 25,000 students in 81 elementary and middle schools. The study was designed to address two questions: Do students in “A” and “B” schools have high average achievement and small achievement gaps compared to students in “D” and “F” schools? What is the difference in average achievement and achievement gaps between school grades when holding constant contextual school conditions? Results We found test score gaps attributed to Free and Reduced Lunch qualification and minority status. Free and Reduced Lunch and minority students average about one standard deviation lower in math and reading than their peers. Test score gaps varied across A–F school grades with the largest gaps existing in “A” and “B” schools. HLM results showed that A–F grades do not differentiate schools by effectiveness levels. For reading, we did not find statistically significant main effects attributed to letter grades. For math, the only statistically significance difference was between students in “A” and “B” schools and students in “F” schools. This difference had a small effect size. School grades did moderate achievement gaps, but gaps moved in a direction opposite from what would be desired of an accountability system that measured achievement equity. Conclusions Progress made under NCLB in exposing achievement inequity in the U.S. has taken a step back with Oklahoma's A–F school grades. Our evidence suggests that a composite letter grade provides very little meaningful information about achievement differences.

High School Exit Exam Scores and University Performance

The Lower-Order Expectations of High-Stakes Tests: A Four-State Analysis of Social Studies Standards and Test Alignment

Improving Mathematics Skills of High School Students

. Cultural, economic, and educational predictors of school exit exam scores in Azerbaijan

A Cross-Sectional Evaluation of Student Achievement Using Standardized and Performance-Based Tests

Evaluating the fairness of a high-stakes college entrance exam in Kuwait

Performance on Reading Comprehension Assessments and College Achievement: A Meta-Analysis

Why test? Talent loss and enrollment loss

Grading Teacher Performance Appraisal Systems: Understanding the Implications of Student Test Scores and Performance Information Use

UC and the SAT: Predictive Validity and Differential Impact of the SAT I and SAT II at the University of California

Do College Entrance Examination Scores Predict Undergraduate GPAs? A Tale of Two Universities

Public Board Score Reporting Undermines Holistic Review for Residency Selection

COMPARING HIGH SCHOOLS WITH RESPECT TO STUDENT PERFORMANCE IN UNIVERSITY

The Informational Significance of A–F School Accountability Grades

The Education of English Language Learners in Arizona: A History of Underachievement

Teacher-assigned grades and external exams: sources of discrepancy

HESI Admission Assessment, HESI Radiography Exit Exam, and ARRT Outcomes

Comparing the accuracy of different scoring methods for identifying sixth graders at risk of failing a state writing assessment

Inter-school variations in the standard of examiners' graduation-level OSCE judgements

Testing the test: Are exams measuring understanding?

Optional Exam Retakes Reduce Anxiety but may Exacerbate Score Disparities Between Students with Different Social Identities