Insider Trading and Stock Price Synchronicity
Can HUANG,Shanmin LI,Mingming ZHUANG,Zhihong HUANG
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1672-0334.2017.06.001
2017-01-01
Journal of Management Science
Abstract:The costs and benefits of insider trading and the need for regulation have been a topic of heated discussions in the fi-nance research field.Insider trading destroy the market order and damage the interests of other investors.One view is that insider trading makes an important contribution with regard to the timely and accurate incorporation of firm-specific information into stock price, and improves stock price efficiency.Logically, insider trading seems to bring firm-specific information objectively and make a lower stock price synchronicity.However, we are skeptical of this. Based on the analysis of stock price synchronicity in the Chinese stock market, we select a dataset of Chinese listed firms from 2007 to 2015 as samples.We use STATA software and OLS regression analysis method for controlling industry and year fixed effect to make an empirical test of the real relationship between insider trading and stock price synchronicity.PIN(probabil-ity of informed trading) has been used to measure the level of insider trading.This study further examines the effect of insider trading on stock price synchronicity with suspicious attitude.To elaborate, we further discuss the influence of information envi-ronment on the relationship aforementioned.In order to make this conclusion more convincing, this paper examines the modera-ting effect of the information environment from macro, meso, and micro perspectives.In order to have a comprehensive and ob-jective understanding of the real impact of insider trading, we try to divide the impact of insider trading on stock price synchronic-ity into the impact of long term and the impact of short term. The results of this paper show that insider trading can lower stock price synchronicity in the current period.But this is not the whole story.It has been found that insider trading is an informal channel of information transfer, whose impact depends on the information environment.When the information environment is better, the negative impact of insider trading on stock price synchronicity in the current period is weaker.And when the information environment is worse, the negative impact of insider trading on stock price synchronicity in the current period is stronger.Moreover, it has also been found that informed trading may dispirit the non-informed traders and improve stock price synchronicity in the future, which destroy the efficiency of capital mar-ket eventually. Our findings, to a certain extent, explore the real impact of insider trading and refute the view that insider trading can im-prove the efficiency of the capital market, and enhance investors and regulators′comprehension of the capital market of China.