Abstract:Despite the proven effectiveness of influenza vaccines, vaccination coverage remains suboptimal globally. Descriptive norms messaging highlighting low influenza vaccination rates is often presented to the public. This study investigated the influence of descriptive norms on influenza vaccination intentions and assessed whether the interaction of value framing with herd-immunity threshold moderates this effect. Utilizing an online experiment, a 2 (descriptive norms: 20% vs. 80%) × 2 (value framing: individual immunity vs. herd immunity) × 2 (herd-immunity threshold: uncertain vs. 90%) between-subjects fractional design was conducted with 803 participants (female 62%, mean age 31 years). The results revealed that low descriptive norms decreased influenza vaccination intention by amplifying concerns about the vaccine's safety and effectiveness. While framing the value of herd immunity increased vaccination intention when the herd-immunity threshold was uncertain, it did not mitigate the negative impact of low descriptive norms. These findings offer novel insights into the cognitive mechanisms underpinning norm-based social influence on vaccination intentions and suggest that public health officials should exercise caution when presenting vaccine coverage statistics to the public to avoid inadvertently discouraging vaccination.

Understanding the mechanisms behind descriptive norms on influenza vaccination intention: the role of concerns about vaccine safety and effectiveness