Abstract:While cross entropy (CE) is the most commonly used loss to train deep neural networks for classification tasks, many alternative losses have been developed to obtain better empirical performance. Among them, which one is the best to use is still a mystery, because there seem to be multiple factors affecting the answer, such as properties of the dataset, the choice of network architecture, and so on. This paper studies the choice of loss function by examining the last-layer features of deep networks, drawing inspiration from a recent line work showing that the global optimal solution of CE and mean-square-error (MSE) losses exhibits a Neural Collapse phenomenon. That is, for sufficiently large networks trained until convergence, (i) all features of the same class collapse to the corresponding class mean and (ii) the means associated with different classes are in a configuration where their pairwise distances are all equal and maximized. We extend such results and show through global solution and landscape analyses that a broad family of loss functions including commonly used label smoothing (LS) and focal loss (FL) exhibits Neural Collapse. Hence, all relevant losses(i.e., CE, LS, FL, MSE) produce equivalent features on training data. Based on the unconstrained feature model assumption, we provide either the global landscape analysis for LS loss or the local landscape analysis for FL loss and show that the (only!) global minimizers are neural collapse solutions, while all other critical points are strict saddles whose Hessian exhibit negative curvature directions either in the global scope for LS loss or in the local scope for FL loss near the optimal solution. The experiments further show that Neural Collapse features obtained from all relevant losses lead to largely identical performance on test data as well, provided that the network is sufficiently large and trained until convergence.

Stability for the training of deep neural networks and other classifiers

Stability of accuracy for the training of DNNs via the uniform doubling condition

Do stable neural networks exist for classification problems? -- A new view on stability in AI

Can Stability be Detrimental? Better Generalization through Gradient Descent Instabilities

The Boundaries of Verifiable Accuracy, Robustness, and Generalisation in Deep Learning

Measuring and Mitigating Local Instability in Deep Neural Networks

Improving the Robustness of Deep Neural Networks via Stability Training

Exploring the Stability Gap in Continual Learning: The Role of the Classification Head

Inconsistency, Instability, and Generalization Gap of Deep Neural Network Training

Stability Analysis and Generalization Bounds of Adversarial Training

Overcoming the Stability Gap in Continual Learning

Dynamics in Deep Classifiers Trained with the Square Loss: Normalization, Low Rank, Neural Collapse, and Generalization Bounds

Dynamic Learning Rate for Neural Networks: A Fixed-Time Stability Approach

Stability of decision trees and logistic regression

Noise Stability Optimization for Finding Flat Minima: A Hessian-based Regularization Approach

Understanding Edge-of-Stability Training Dynamics with a Minimalist Example

Noise Sensitivity and Stability of Deep Neural Networks for Binary Classification

Data-Dependent Stability Analysis of Adversarial Training

Are All Losses Created Equal: A Neural Collapse Perspective

Stability and Generalization in Free Adversarial Training