Abstract:As the urgency to achieve net-zero emissions by 2050 intensifies, industries face an imperative to reimagine their role in the fight against climate change. One promising avenue arises from the realization that industrial emissions, often deemed pollutants, can be the building blocks of a circular economy strategy. By directly utilizing these carbon emissions as raw materials, we can produce net-zero or low-carbon fuels, carbonates, polymers, and chemicals. At the heart of this paradigm shift lies the production of carbon-neutral methanol from industrial flue gas-a technically viable approach that has gained significant momentum in recent years. The conditions under which such a circular economy model for producing renewable methanol becomes commercially sustainable based on realistic constraints, however, are not sufficiently explored in the existing literature. This paper fills this gap by investigating if and when net-zero methanol production from industrial flue gas will be a sustainable long-term strategy. Using detailed technoeconomic modeling of integrated hydrogen and methanol production ecosystems for two production capacities, I will evaluate 32 practical production scenarios using realistic regulatory, economic, and market conditions. Even though renewable methanol from industrial emissions can be a viable technical solution to address climate change and global warming, I will show why this strategy will be commercially feasible only under favorable economic, regulatory, and market conditions. Furthermore, I will demonstrate how the market price of methanol and the cost of carbon-free electricity critically influence the commercial feasibility of this approach. When these two parameters are unfavorable, I will show why other factors, namely, carbon credits and byproduct (oxygen) sales, will not be sufficient to create an economically sustainable circular economy of renewable methanol from industrial emissions. Finally, I will provide arguments on why one has to think through stakeholder cooperation and public-private partnerships to mitigate various project risks. Despite the importance of this topic, it is not sufficiently covered in the available scientific literature. To advance policy and regulatory frameworks in this area, I strongly believe that further research and development is needed. I will also share perspectives on regulatory derisking mechanisms, which can help align regulations with private investors' preferences. With the analyses and arguments showcased in this paper, I will firmly assert that without favorable conditions, strong partnerships, and stakeholder cooperation, the production of renewable net-zero methanol from industrial emissions risks becoming a dead-end strategy.

Global production potential of green methanol based on variable renewable electricity

Feasibility Study of Renewable E-Methanol Production: A Substitution Pathway from Blue to Green

A near-zero carbon emission methanol production through CO2 hydrogenation integrated with renewable hydrogen: Process analysis, modification and evaluation

Green Methanol—An Important Pathway to Realize Carbon Neutrality

Flexible Methanol Production Process Using Biomass/ Municipal Solid Waste and Hydrogen Produced by Electrolysis and Natural Gas Pyrolysis

From fossil to green chemicals: Sustainable pathways and new carbon feedstocks for the global chemical industry

Techno-economic analysis and optimisation of grey and green methanol synthesis using flowsheet automation and surrogate modelling

Towards a sustainable, and economic production future: Proposing a new process for methanol production based on renewable hydrogen

E-Methanol Production and Potential Export in the Northern Denmark Region for 2030 and 2045

Power and biogas to methanol – A techno-economic analysis of carbon-maximized green methanol production via two reforming approaches

Assessment of Green Methanol Production Potential and Related Economic and Environmental Benefits: The Case of China

Quantitative Design of a New e-Methanol Production Process

Alternative sustainable routes to methanol production: Techno-economic and environmental assessment

Cost Projection of Global Green Hydrogen Production Scenarios

Renewable Methanol from Industrial Carbon Emissions: A Dead End or Sustainable Way Forward?

Methanol, a Plugin Marine Fuel for Green House Gas Reduction—A Review

Conceptual Process Design and Technoeconomic Analysis of an e-Methanol Plant with Direct Air-Captured CO 2 and Electrolytic H 2

Energy-environment-economy(3E) assessment of a novel low-carbon emission process integrating coal-to-methanol with green hydrogen

A multi-dimensional feasibility analysis of coal to methanol assisted by green hydrogen from a life cycle viewpoint

Techno-Economic Analysis of Blue Methanol Production from Natural Gas with Carbon Capture in Indonesia

A Review of The Methanol Economy: The Fuel Cell Route