Abstract:Effective thermal management is crucial for safely operating lithium-ion batteries, particularly under high discharge rates and abusive conditions. This study compares the thermal performance, weight, and power consumption of various cooling methods under normal operating and abusive conditions, including air, liquids, and phase change materials (PCMs). The Newman, Tiedemann, Gu, and Kim (NTGK) model is used to simulate the thermal behavior of a 14.6 Ah lithium-ion battery at discharge rates of 1C, 6C, and 10C. Under normal operating conditions, water cooling emerges as the best option due to its superior balance of thermal performance, lower power consumption, and minimal weight addition, making it ideal for regular operation. In contrast, air cooling is inadequate for high discharge rates and abusive conditions, with battery temperatures reaching up to 160 °C under an internal short circuit, posing a severe risk of thermal runaway. Among the PCMs, n-octadecane is identified as the most effective, maintaining battery temperatures below 40 °C at discharge rates up to 10C while offering an energy-efficient solution without power consumption. The PCM/graphite composite, with its higher melting point and thermal conductivity, performs better in battery thermal management under high ambient temperatures, with a maximum temperature difference of 3.91 °C. The impact of short circuits on maximum battery temperature is evaluated for internal resistances ranging from 0.1 to 1μΩ. Results indicate that liquid metal cooling ensures the battery operates within the optimal temperature range across all resistances. However, using PCM/graphite composite for resistances less than 0.5μΩ and employing water or nanofluid for resistance of 0.1μΩ results in a temperature increase beyond the allowable limit. The impact of adding nanoparticles on reducing battery temperature is more significant under abusive conditions than under normal operating conditions. This study advances previous efforts by comprehensively comparing cooling methods across various operating and extreme conditions, offering critical insights for optimizing battery thermal management systems.

Novel thermal management methods to improve the performance of the Li-ion batteries in high discharge current applications

Thermal management analysis using heat pipe in the high current discharging of lithium-ion battery in electric vehicles

Heat pipe air-cooled thermal management system for lithium-ion batteries: High power applications

Numerical study on heat dissipation performance of a lithium-ion battery module based on immersion cooling

Performance evaluation of a hydrostatic flow immersion cooling system for high-current discharge Li-ion batteries

Modeling and Analysis of Heat Dissipation for Liquid Cooling Lithium-Ion Batteries

Performance characteristics of a novel heat pipe-assisted liquid cooling system for the thermal management of lithium-ion batteries

Comparison of different cooling techniques for a lithium-ion battery at various discharge rates using electrochemical thermal modeling

Numerical Study on Heat Dissipation and Structure Optimization of Immersed Liquid Cooling Mode Used in 280ah LiFePO4 Batteries

Experimental investigation and comparative analysis of immersion cooling of lithium-ion batteries using mineral and therminol oil

Numerical Study on Heat Dissipation and Structure Optimization of Immersed Liquid Cooling Mode Used in 280ah LiFePO4 4 Batteries

Heat Dissipation Design for Lithium-Ion Batteries

Experimental study of a direct evaporative cooling approach for Li‐ion battery thermal management

A new concept of thermal management system in Li-ion battery using air cooling and heat pipe for electric vehicles

Numerical and experimental investigations on heat transfer characteristics and influencing factors of immersion cooling system for high-capacity prismatic lithium-ion battery

Parametric Investigation on the Performance of a Battery Thermal Management System with Immersion Cooling

Numerical and Experimental Investigation on the Performance of Battery Thermal Management System Based on Micro Heat Pipe Array

A Review of Thermal Management and Heat Transfer of Lithium-Ion Batteries

Lithium–ion Battery Thermal Management Using Heat Pipe and Phase Change Material During Discharge–charge Cycle: A Comprehensive Numerical Study

Investigation of Heat Transfer Enhancement Techniques on a Scalable Novel Hybrid Thermal Management Strategy for Lithium-Ion Battery Packs

Experimental and Numerical Analysis of a Hybrid Thermal Management Concept at Different Discharge Rates for a Cylindrical Li-Ion Battery Module