Lessons learned: establishing a CLIA-equivalent laboratory for targeted mass spectrometry assays – navigating the transition from research to clinical practice

Chia-Li Han,Chi-Ting Lai,Aaron James Reyes,Hao-Chin Yang,Jin-Ying Lu,Shyang-Rong Shih,Kuen-Yuan Chen,Andrew N. Hoofnagle,Sung-Liang Yu,William Bocik,Tara Hiltke,Huan-Chi Chiu,Ching-Yi Wan,Henry Rodriguez,Victoria Zhang,Yu-Ju Chen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12014-024-09455-y
2024-02-24
Clinical Proteomics
Abstract:Mass spectrometry (MS) assays offer exceptional capabilities in high multiplexity, specificity, and throughput. As proteomics technologies continue advancements to identify new disease biomarkers, transition of these innovations from research settings to clinical applications becomes imperative. To meet the rigorous regulatory standards of clinical laboratories, development of a clinical protein MS assay necessitates adherence to stringent criteria. To illustrate the process, this project focused on using thyroglobulin (Tg) as a biomarker and an immuno-multiple reaction monitoring (iMRM) MS-based assay as a model for establishing a Clinical Laboratory Improvement Amendments (CLIA) compliant laboratory within the Centers of Genomic and Precision Medicine, National Taiwan University. The chosen example also illustrates the clinical utility of MS assays to complement conventional immunoassay-based methods, particularly in cases where the presence of autoantibodies in 10–30% of patients hinders accuracy. The laboratory design entails a comprehensive coordination in spatial layout, workflow organization, equipment selection, ventilation systems, plumbing, electrical infrastructure, documentation procedures, and communication protocols. Practical aspects of the transformation process, including preparing laboratory facilities, testing environments, instrument validation, assay development and validation, quality management, sample testing, and personnel competency, are discussed. Finally, concordant results in proficiency testing demonstrate the harmonization with the University of Washington Medical Center and the quality assurance of the CLIA-equivalent Tg-iMRM MS assay established in Taiwan. The realization of this model protein MS assay in Taiwan highlights the feasibility of international joint development and provides a detailed reference map to expedite the implementation of more MS-based protein assays in clinical laboratories for patient care.
biochemical research methods
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve This paper aims to address the challenges encountered in clinical laboratories when using traditional immunoassay methods to detect thyroglobulin (Tg). Specifically: 1. **Limitations of Traditional Immunoassay Methods**: Currently, immunoassay methods (such as immunometric assays) are the primary means for monitoring postoperative recurrence or residual lesions in patients with differentiated thyroid cancer (DTC). However, approximately 20%-30% of patients have anti-thyroglobulin autoantibodies (TgAb) in their bodies, which interfere with immunoassays, leading to an underestimation of Tg concentration and affecting diagnostic accuracy. 2. **Improving Diagnostic Accuracy**: To overcome the aforementioned issues, the research team introduced a novel quantitative method based on mass spectrometry—immuno-multiple reaction monitoring (iMRM) mass spectrometry. This method selectively captures and quantifies specific peptides of thyroglobulin, avoiding interference from autoantibodies and improving detection accuracy and reliability. 3. **Establishing a CLIA-Compliant Clinical Laboratory**: The research team's goal is to establish a clinical laboratory in Taiwan that complies with the standards of the U.S. Clinical Laboratory Improvement Amendments (CLIA) to enable the clinical application of the iMRM mass spectrometry method. This includes the renovation of laboratory infrastructure, instrument validation, method development and validation, and the establishment of a quality management system. 4. **International Joint Development and Standardization**: Through collaboration with the University of Washington Medical Center in the U.S., the research team demonstrated the alignment of the Taiwan laboratory with international standards, providing detailed references for the implementation of more mass spectrometry-based protein detection methods in clinical laboratories. ### Summary By developing and validating a new iMRM mass spectrometry method, this paper addresses the issue of autoantibody interference in traditional immunoassay methods for detecting thyroglobulin. It successfully established a CLIA-compliant clinical laboratory, providing strong support for improving the accuracy and reliability of clinical diagnostics.