Abstract:Recently we uploaded to the arxiv a paper entitled: Improving the Economic Complexity Index. There, we compared three metrics of the knowledge intensity of an economy, the original metric we published in 2009 (the Economic Complexity Index or ECI), a variation of the metric proposed in 2012, and a variation we called ECI+. It was brought to our attention that the definition of ECI+ was equivalent to the variation of the metric proposed in 2012. We have verified this claim, and found that while the equations are not exactly the same, they are similar enough to be our own oversight. More importantly, we now ask: how many variations of the original ECI work? In this paper we provide a simple unifying framework to explore multiple variations of ECI, including both the original 2009 ECI and the 2012 variation. We found that a large fraction of variations have a similar predictive power, indicating that the chance of finding a variation of ECI that works, after the seminal 2009 measure, are surprisingly high. In fact, more than 28 percent of these variations have a predictive power that is within 90 percent of the maximum for any variation. These findings show that, once the idea of measuring economic complexity was out, creating a variation with a similar predictive power (like the ones proposed in 2012) was trivial (a 1 in 3 shot). More importantly, the result show that using exports data to measure the knowledge intensity of an economy is a robust phenomenon that works for multiple functional forms. Moreover, the fact that multiple variations of the 2009 ECI perform close to the maximum, tells us that no variation of ECI will have a performance that is substantially better. This suggests that research efforts should focus on uncovering the mechanisms that contribute to the diffusion and accumulation of productive knowledge instead of on exploring small variations to existing measures.

A simple measure of economic complexity

Improving the Economic Complexity Index

Toward Better Growth Policies in a Modern Economy: the Comparison of Three Complexity Indices.

Measuring economic complexity of countries and products: which metric to use?

Economic Complexity Unfolded: Interpretable Model for the Productive Structure of Economies

Interpreting economic complexity

Economic Complexity: why we like "Complexity weighted diversification"

729 new measures of economic complexity (Addendum to Improving the Economic Complexity Index)

On Measuring Complexity in a Post-Industrial Economy: the Ecosystem’s Approach

Economic and technological complexity: A model study of indicators of knowledge-based innovation systems

A Reasoning of Economic Complexity Based on Simulated General Equilibrium International Trade Model

Linking Economic Complexity, Institutions, and Income Inequality

Accounting for Revealed Comparative Advantage: Economic Complexity Redux

AN ECO-SYSTEMS APPROACH TO CONSTRUCTING ECONOMIC COMPLEXITY MEASURES: ENDOGENIZATION OF THE TECHNOLOGICAL DIMENSION USING LOTKA-VOLTERRA EQUATIONS

The Network Structure of Economic Output

Economic complexity and growth: Can value-added exports better explain the link?

Exploring the Relationship Between Economic Complexity and Resource Efficiency

Quantifying China's Regional Economic Complexity

The Building Blocks of Economic Complexity

The complex dynamics of products and its asymptotic properties

A new and stable estimation method of country economic fitness and product complexity