Bringing Self-Determination Theory to the Forefront: Examining How Human Resource Practices Motivate Employees of All Ages to Succeed

Rick A. Laguerre,Janet L. Barnes-Farrell
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10869-024-09951-w
IF: 6.604
2024-05-09
Journal of Business and Psychology
Abstract:Self-determination theory (SDT) is widely used in human resource (HR) practice studies to explain how HR practices impact work outcomes. However, there is little empirical evidence establishing the complete SDT mediational process in the HR domain, which entails basic psychological needs and motivation acting as mediators of relations between HR practices and work outcomes. The present study addresses this issue with a mixed methods approach. Using an item classification task with subject matter experts ( N = 48), HR practices were classified as autonomy-, competence-, and relatedness-supportive. Based on this scheme, we tested an SDT-based conceptual model in a three-wave sample of working adults ( N = 818). Results from Multilevel Structural Equation Modeling (MSEM) support the hypothesized model: basic psychological need satisfaction and autonomous motivation mediate the relationship between HR practice perceptions and work outcomes (performance, thriving, affective organizational commitment, and turnover intentions). Autonomy-supportive practices had a positive effect on autonomy need satisfaction, while competence-supportive practices had positive associations with all three basic psychological needs. Counterintuitively, relatedness-supportive practices had negative effects on autonomy and competence need satisfaction, and the relationship between relatedness-supportive practices and autonomy need satisfaction was moderated by chronological age. We discuss our findings in the context of prominent HR studies that utilize SDT and offer a supplemental age-inclusive HR practice scheme for HR managers interested in understanding the benefits of supporting basic psychological needs from both a motivation and workforce retention standpoint.
psychology, applied,business
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily aims to address specific issues in the application of motivation theory in Human Resources (HR) practices, particularly how to motivate employees of different age groups to achieve success through HR practices. In this process, it delves into the application of Self-Determination Theory (SDT). Specifically, the main objectives of the study include: 1. **Establishing a complete SDT mediation process**: In the field of human resource management, although Self-Determination Theory is widely mentioned as a way to explain how HR practices affect work outcomes, few empirical studies have been able to fully validate the mediation process within this theoretical framework, namely the mediating role of basic psychological needs satisfaction and intrinsic motivation between HR practices and work outcomes. 2. **Examining the impact of HR practices on the basic psychological needs of employees of different age groups**: The study uses a mixed-methods approach to explore how three types of HR practices—autonomy support, competence support, and relatedness support—affect the satisfaction of employees' basic psychological needs, while considering the potential moderating effect of age. 3. **Validating the applicability and limitations of SDT in the HR field**: Through an analysis of previous literature, it was found that although many studies have mentioned the importance of SDT, actual research designs often fail to fully validate the core assumptions of the theory, such as the relationship between basic psychological needs satisfaction and intrinsic motivation. This study attempts to fill this gap by empirically validating the core assumptions of SDT. 4. **Exploring the moderating role of age in the relationship between HR practices and basic psychological needs**: Based on life cycle development theory, the study hypothesizes that age will moderate the impact of HR practices on the satisfaction of basic psychological needs. For example, as age increases, employees' needs for autonomy, competence, and relatedness may change, thereby affecting the effectiveness of HR practices. In summary, this paper attempts to place Self-Determination Theory at the forefront of HR practice research through empirical studies, to better understand how meeting employees' basic psychological needs can improve their job performance and organizational commitment, reduce turnover intentions, and promote a positive work mindset. Additionally, the study focuses on the important role of age in this process.