Immigration, wages, and employment under informal labor markets

Lukas Delgado-Prieto

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00148-024-01028-5

IF: 4.7

2024-05-26

Journal of Population Economics

Abstract:This paper studies the labor market impacts of the Venezuelan immigration in Colombia. Exploiting spatial variation in exposure, I find a negative effect on native wages driven by the informal sector (where immigrants are concentrated) and a reduction in native employment in the formal sector (where the minimum wage binds for many workers). To explain this, I build a model in which a firm substitutes formal for informal labor in response to lower informal wages. Consistent with the model's predictions, I document that the decrease in formal employment is driven by small firms that use both labor types in production and by workers earning the minimum wage.

economics,demography

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the impact of Venezuelan immigration on the Colombian labor market, particularly on local wages and employment. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects:

1. **Impact of immigration on local wages**: The study finds that the influx of Venezuelan immigrants leads to a decrease in the hourly wages of locals. For every 1 percentage point increase in the proportion of Venezuelan immigrants in the employed population, local wages decrease by an average of approximately 1.5% to 1.7%.

2. **Impact of immigration on local employment**: The study finds that the increase in immigration leads to a decrease in the employment rate of locals. For every 1 percentage point increase in the proportion of Venezuelan immigrants in the employed population, the employment rate of locals decreases by approximately 0.9% to 1.3%.

3. **Differences between formal and informal sectors**: The paper further analyzes the different impacts of immigration on the formal and informal sectors. In the informal sector, due to the lack of minimum wage restrictions, wages can be adjusted more flexibly, leading to a significant decrease in wages with the influx of immigrants. In the formal sector, due to the rigidity of the minimum wage, wage changes are not significant, but the employment rate decreases, especially for workers whose income is close to the minimum wage.

4. **Changes in firm behavior**: The paper constructs a model explaining how firms, when faced with lower informal wages, substitute informal labor for formal labor, leading to a reduction in formal sector employment.

5. **Policy recommendations**: The paper points out that a higher minimum wage may amplify the negative employment effects in the formal sector. In Colombia, the ratio of the minimum wage to the median wage reached 82.6% in 2015, the highest among all OECD countries, exacerbating the negative impact of immigration on the labor market.

Overall, the paper explores the multifaceted impact of Venezuelan immigration on the Colombian labor market through empirical analysis and theoretical models, and provides relevant policy recommendations.