The Index of Parental Activities, Context and Experiences (I-PACE): Psychometric Properties of a New Brief Early Parenting Questionnaire

Claire Hughes,Rory T. Devine,Naomi White,Elian Fink
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10826-024-02793-3
2024-03-13
Journal of Child and Family Studies
Abstract:Time pressures make brevity important for parent self-report measures, yet evidence highlights the multi-faceted nature of parenting and contextual influences. To straddle these competing goals, we developed a brief (23-item) yet broad Index of Parental Activities, Context, and Experiences (I-PACE) aimed at parents of toddlers and pre-schoolers. In two studies we assessed the validity and reliability of the I-PACE. Study 1 involved 870 caregivers (95% female, 75% with degrees, 90% White British) and examined I-PACE ratings alongside; (a) ratings of children's social-emotional skills and behavior problems; and (b) child age and parental depressive symptoms, to assess its sensitivity to contrasts in child development and parental experience. Study 2 included 191 families with 14-month-olds, for whom 188 mothers and 178 fathers completed the I-PACE and an index of life satisfaction. Supporting the replicability of findings from the I-PACE, both studies showed the same differentiated 5-factor structure (i.e., parental experiences, parenting activities, home environment quality, neighborhood environment quality and childcare environment quality). Supporting the I-PACE's validity, Study 1 showed that all 5 factors were independently related to both children's social-emotional skills and behavior problems, with predicted associations with child age and parental depressive symptoms. Supporting the I-PACE's inter-rater reliability, within-couple associations were significant for parenting activities, home environment, neighborhood quality and childcare quality. Together, these findings indicate that the I-PACE offers a broad yet brief index of early parenting with good psychometric properties and we discuss promising avenues for future research.
family studies,psychology, developmental,psychiatry
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the lack of reliable and effective measurement tools in the early - childhood rearing environment. Specifically, the researchers developed a short but comprehensive questionnaire - the Index of Parental Activities, Context, and Experiences (I - PACE) - aiming to assess various aspects of parents' behaviors, feelings, and environmental factors in the parenting process. Through two studies, the paper evaluated the validity and reliability of I - PACE to verify whether it can accurately reflect the influence of parents' behaviors, emotions, and the environment on young children's social - emotional skills and behavioral problems. ### Main Objectives: 1. **Establish the Reliability and Validity of I - PACE**: Test the latent factor structure of I - PACE through Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA) and examine the fairness of items through Differential Item Functioning (DIF) analysis. 2. **Verify the Validity of I - PACE**: Evaluate the predictive validity of I - PACE through correlation analysis with the scores of children's social - emotional skills and behavioral problems (using the Brief Infant Toddler Social Emotional Assessment, BITSEA). 3. **Evaluate the Sensitivity of I - PACE**: Examine the sensitivity of I - PACE in children of different age groups and in terms of parents' depressive symptoms. ### Research Methods: - **Participants**: 870 caregivers (mostly female, mostly highly educated, mainly white) were recruited from the United Kingdom and Ireland. - **Tools**: The I - PACE questionnaire contains 23 items, divided into five dimensions: parental experience, parenting activities, family environment quality, community environment quality, and childcare environment quality. In addition, BITSEA was used to assess children's behavioral problems and social - emotional abilities, and PHQ - 2 was used to assess parents' depressive symptoms. - **Data Analysis**: Mplus software was used for confirmatory factor analysis to evaluate model fit; DIFAS software was used for DIF analysis to examine item fairness; finally, Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) was used to analyze the relationships between the various dimensions of I - PACE and children's behavioral problems and social - emotional abilities. ### Results: - **Factor Structure**: The five - factor model (parental experience, parenting activities, family environment, community environment, and childcare environment) showed the best fit. - **Item Fairness**: DIF analysis showed that most items were consistent among participants of different genders, ages, races, and education levels, and a few items had significant DIF. - **Validity**: All five dimensions of I - PACE were significantly related to children's social - emotional skills and behavioral problems, and were also associated with children's ages and parents' depressive symptoms. ### Conclusion: I - PACE is a short but comprehensive questionnaire that can effectively assess various aspects of parents' behaviors, feelings, and environmental factors in the parenting process and has good psychometric properties. This provides researchers and practitioners with a reliable tool for assessing the social environment in early childhood.