Characterization of Polyhexamethylene Guanidine Oligomers in Solutions and Aerosols Emitted during Humidifier Use

Sunju Kim,Chungsik Yoon
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1155/2024/7477565
IF: 6.5539
2024-01-06
Indoor Air
Abstract:The behavior of polyhexamethylene guanidine (PHMG), the causative agent of many humidifier-induced lung diseases, is not well known because of its various oligomer structures and analytical difficulties. The aim of this study was to identify different PHMG oligomer types both in solution and aerosols and to estimate the airborne concentration of oligomers during humidifier use. Three products containing PHMG as the main component were diluted to the manufacturer’s recommended concentration (6.5 ppm) or the worst-case concentration (65 ppm or 125 ppm). Samples were qualitatively and quantitatively analyzed with liquid chromatography-quadrupole time-of-flight (LC-qToF) mass spectrometry in the diluted solution and in the air at 0.5 m and 1 m. The LC-qToF data were processed using UNIFI software to characterize the PHMG structure. For all products in both the humidifier solution and air, the linear type was predominant over the branched/cyclic structure, but each product had different characteristics. The linear structure in the Oxy product, the main product of lung diseases, accounted for 90.6%, while that of the Scunder and BOC Sciences’ products accounted for 78.6% and 75.8%, respectively. The concentration of the oligomer in air for the Oxy product was estimated to be 35.89 and 390.96 μg/m3 at 6.5 and 65 ppm, respectively. Most of the oligomers in the solution were found in air at a short distance (0.5 m), with a negligible concentration beyond 1 m. Oligomers with 1–7 monomer units were identified in the humidifier solution, whereas mainly monomers, dimers, and trimers were identified in the air. The results of this study will facilitate further investigations of the mechanisms of lung disease by identifying the behaviors and forms of PHMG in the air, along with previously revealed toxicity results.
engineering, environmental,public, environmental & occupational health,construction & building technology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the behavior of polyhexamethylene guanidine (PHMG) released into the air during the use of humidifiers and its potential health risks. Specifically, the research aims to identify the forms of different types of PHMG oligomers in solutions and aerosols, and estimate the concentration of oligomers in the air during the use of humidifiers. Since PHMG is the cause of many humidifier - induced lung diseases, but the various oligomer structures and the difficulty of analysis make the understanding of its behavior insufficient, so this research fills this gap. ### Main research contents: 1. **Identification of different types of PHMG oligomers**: The research uses liquid chromatography - quadrupole time - of - flight mass spectrometry (LC - qToF - MS) technology to conduct qualitative and quantitative analysis on three PHMG - containing products in diluted solutions and in the air to identify different types of PHMG oligomers. 2. **Estimation of oligomer concentration in the air**: The research measures the oligomer concentration of PHMG solutions at different concentrations (6.5 ppm, 65 ppm, 125 ppm) released into the air during the use of humidifiers. 3. **Analysis of the distribution of oligomers in the air**: The research explores the distribution of different oligomers in the air, especially the concentration changes at different distances (0.5 m and 1 m). ### Research background: - **Uses of PHMG**: From 1994 to 2011, humidifier disinfectants containing polyhexamethylene guanidine (PHMG) were widely used in South Korea to prevent microbial contamination in ultrasonic humidifier water tanks. - **Health risks**: Although serious lung damage is caused by inhaling aerosols containing humidifier disinfectants, PHMG - containing disinfectant products are still sold and widely used in the market. Until it was recognized that these products were the main cause of most deaths, the South Korean government has banned the sale of PHMG since 2011. - **Research significance**: At present, the research on PHMG mainly focuses on raw materials, while there is less research on its behavior in the air and the identification of different subtypes. This research, through detailed chemical characterization, is helpful for further investigation of the mechanism of lung diseases. ### Methods: - **Sample preparation**: The research uses three PHMG - containing products, which are respectively diluted to the recommended concentration (6.5 ppm) or the worst - case concentration (65 ppm or 125 ppm). - **Experimental device**: Experiments are carried out using an ultrasonic humidifier in a 40.3 - cubic - meter sterile room, and the humidifier spray volume is set to the maximum. - **Data analysis**: LC - qToF - MS technology is used for analysis, and UNIFI software is used for data processing to accurately identify target substances and improve the accuracy of PHMG oligomer classification. ### Results: - **Oligomer types**: Linear structures (A - C types) are dominant in all products, but each product has different characteristics. For example, in the Oxy product, the linear structure A2 has the highest proportion, while in the Scunder and BOC products, the linear structures C2 and C1 have the highest proportions. - **Concentration of oligomers in the air**: As the concentration of PHMG in the solution increases, the concentration of PHMG detected in the air also increases significantly. For example, when the solution concentration of the Oxy product increases from 6.5 ppm to 65 ppm, the total PHMG concentration detected in the air increases by about 10.9 times. - **Distribution of oligomers in the air**: Most oligomers are detected at 0.5 m, and the concentration at 1 m is very low. Oligomers mainly exist in the air in the forms of monomers, dimers and trimers. ### Discussion: - **Behavior of oligomers in the air**: The research finds that smaller molecules are more likely to be released into the air, and the concentration at 0.5 m is higher than that at 1 m. This may be because the driving force of the humidifier is stronger at short distances, while at 1 m the driving force is significantly weakened, the spray angle becomes larger, resulting in a sharp drop in concentration. - **Health risks**: Previous epidemiological studies have shown that humidifiers are mainly used in children's bedrooms, and when the distance between the bed and the humidifier is less than 0.5 m, the risk of lung damage increases significantly. In conclusion, this research provides important information for understanding the mechanism of humidifier - induced lung diseases through detailed analysis of the behavior of PHMG oligomers in solutions and in the air, and is helpful for evaluating and managing related health risks.