Now, Later, and Lasting: 10 Priorities for AI Research, Policy, and Practice

Eric Horvitz,Vincent Conitzer,Sheila McIlraith,Peter Stone

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1145/3637866

IF: 22.7

2024-05-23

Communications of the ACM

Abstract:Advances in artificial intelligence (AI) will transform many aspects of our lives and society, bringing immense opportunities but also posing significant risks and challenges. The next several decades may well be a turning point for humanity, comparable to the industrial revolution. If so, future historians will judge how well we harnessed the benefits of AI for humanity, while protecting against potential harms. In this column, we share a set of recommendations for moving forward from the perspective of a founder and leaders of the One Hundred Year Study on AI. 3 Launched 10 years ago with a dedicated endowment, the project is committed to a perpetual series of studies by multidisciplinary experts to evaluate the immediate, longer-term, and far-reaching effects of AI on people and society, 1 and to make recommendations about AI research, policy, and practice. 2 , 4 Beyond these recurrent studies and reports, our initiatives have included related efforts aimed at providing a diverse audience with insights about the trajectory of AI, including the creation of the AI Index , an annual benchmarking of AI progress. 5 As we witness new capabilities emerging from neural models, it is crucial that we engage in efforts to advance our scientific understanding of these models and their behaviors. We must address AI's impact on people and society through technical, social, and sociotechnical lenses, incorporating insights from a diverse range of experts including voices from engineering, social, behavioral, and economic disciplines. By fostering dialogue, collaboration, and action among various stakeholders, we can strategically guide the development and deployment of AI in ways that maximize its potential for contributing to human flourishing. Despite the growing divide in the field between focusing on short-term versus long-term implications, we think both are of critical importance. As Alan Turing—one of the pioneers of AI—wrote in 1950, "We can only see a short distance ahead, but we can see plenty there that needs to be done." 6 We offer the following 10 recommendations for action that collectively address both the short- and long-term potential impacts of AI technologies: Scientific Foundations . Invest deeply in research to extend the scientific understanding of the capabilities and limitations of AI systems. Aim to ascertain the principles underlying their behaviors, identify and address deficiencies, and enable robust human guidance and oversight. Explore a diversity of alternative and complementary AI techniques and prioritize the study of the basis for sudden advances in AI capabilities, such as emergent phenomena observed in neural models as they are scaled. Safety, Reliability, Equity . Boost investments in R&D on identifying and mitigating concerns with safety, fairness, accuracy, and reliability of models, and encourage greater sharing and transparency from organizations building the largest-scale models, particularly regarding their methods, practices, results, and experiences. Advances in technology and policy can foster trust, accountability, and collaboration among the AI community and society at large. Regulation . Devise best practices, audits, and laws and regulations to incentivize reporting on, modifying, and addressing new capabilities and emergent phenomena to ensure that fielded models and systems are safe and responsibly deployed. These efforts can lead to appropriate oversight, feedback, and governance mechanisms aimed at aligning AI systems with human values and interests. Disinformation . Address uses of AI by malicious actors for disinformation, manipulation, and impersonation, which pose a risk to an informed citizenry and to the fabric of our democracies. Beyond harnessing promising technical and sociotechnical strategies built on content provenance, watermarking, and fingerprinting, investigate new laws, regulations, and enforcement to combat these threats while protecting civil liberties. The goal is to safeguard the integrity of information and communication against malevolent repurposing of widely available AI methods to deceive and persuade. Resources . Bridge the academia-industry gap to ensure greater access and enhanced collaboration for scholars and students so they can participate fully in frontier research and address key issues when they first arise rather than when it is too late. Address significant asymmetries in resources and access, spanning data, computation, and analytical tools and models, between academic and private-sector research scientists. Nurturing university-bas -Abstract Truncated-

computer science, theory & methods, software engineering, hardware & architecture

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to ensure that the impact of artificial intelligence (AI) technology on human society is positive while it is developing rapidly, and to reduce potential risks and challenges. Specifically, the paper proposes ten suggestions, aiming to comprehensively address the short - term and long - term impacts of AI technology from multiple aspects such as scientific research, safety, reliability, fairness, regulation, resource allocation, the vitality of educational institutions, employment and economy, diplomacy, and prevention of catastrophic consequences. These suggestions include:

1. **Scientific Foundation**: Conduct in - depth research to expand the understanding of the capabilities and limitations of AI systems, explore diverse AI technologies, and prioritize research on the basic principles that lead to sudden improvements in AI capabilities.
2. **Safety, Reliability, Fairness**: Increase investment in research on identifying and mitigating safety, fairness, accuracy, and reliability issues of models, and encourage sharing and transparency among large - scale model - building organizations.
3. **Regulation**: Develop best practices, audits, and laws and regulations to encourage reporting, modification, and prevention of risks brought by AI.
4. **False Information**: Address the problem of malicious actors using AI to spread false information, manipulate, and misappropriate personal identities, and protect the information integrity and communication security of democratic systems.
5. **Resources**: Narrow the resource gap between academia and industry to ensure that scholars and students can fully participate in frontier research.
6. **Vitality of Academia**: Alleviate the loss of teachers and top - potential students by creating incentive and support structures to maintain the health and vitality of educational institutions.
7. **Employment and Economy**: Strictly monitor the impact of AI technology on employment and economy, and promote technological and policy innovations that promote common prosperity rather than exacerbate economic inequality.
8. **Diplomacy**: Strengthen international diplomatic efforts, cooperate with all countries on the meaning and use of AI, and establish norms for responsible AI practice on a global scale.
9. **Deep - level Impact**: Gain in - depth understanding of the long - term impacts of AI technology on psychological, social, and cultural levels, such as human self - identity, autonomy, and excessive dependence on AI.
10. **Catastrophic Results**: Prioritize the review of potential catastrophic consequences related to AI and adopt forward - looking strategic designs to prevent safety measures from being severely disrupted.

Through these suggestions, the paper aims to guide the development and deployment of AI so that it can contribute maximally to human well - being while protecting society from potential harm.