Modeling and Simulation of Lane-Changing Management Strategies at On-Ramp and Off-Ramp Pair Areas Based on Cellular Automaton

Sicheng Sun,Xu An,Jing Zhao,Peng Li,Haipeng Shao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/access.2021.3062939
IF: 3.9
2021-01-01
IEEE Access
Abstract:In urban expressways, when an on-ramp and off-ramp pair are closely spaced, the operational condition of the downstream diverge area influences that of the adjacent upstream merge area because of the weaving movement and queuing. Although lane-changing management schemes have often been used in practice, the quantification effect of specific management schemes has not been studied in detail. In this paper, a new cellular automaton model that fits in an on-ramp and off-ramp pair area was established, in which three types of lane change behaviors and eight types of lane-changing management schemes are considered. Sensitivity analysis of the simulation results was conducted to validate the effectiveness of the lane-changing management schemes, from which the optimal schemes under various geometric and traffic conditions are recommended. Results show forcing the off-ramp vehicles to change lanes in advance by using lane markings results in higher operational efficiency in most cases.
computer science, information systems,telecommunications,engineering, electrical & electronic
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to solve the problem of low traffic operation efficiency caused by weaving movements and queuing phenomena in urban expressways when the distance between entrance ramps and exit ramps is relatively short. Specifically, the paper focuses on how to improve the traffic operation efficiency in such areas through lane - change management strategies. ### Problem Background On urban expressways, entrance ramps (on - ramp) and exit ramps (off - ramp) are basic components. Due to land use limitations, in some cases, the distance between these pairs of ramps is very close. This layout makes the operation status of the downstream diverge area affect the upstream merge area, resulting in complex traffic conditions and potential congestion problems. ### Research Objectives In order to reduce congestion in the entrance - ramp merge area and the exit - ramp diverge area, researchers have proposed various management and control strategies, such as ramp metering, variable speed limit, high - occupancy/toll lanes, etc. However, the effects of specific lane - change management strategies have not been studied in detail. ### Solutions This paper proposes a new method based on the cellular automaton (CA) model, which is specifically used to simulate and evaluate lane - change management strategies between entrance ramps and exit ramps. The model considers three types of lane - change behaviors and eight lane - change management schemes, and verifies the effectiveness of these management schemes through sensitivity analysis. Finally, the article recommends the optimal lane - change management schemes under different geometric and traffic conditions. ### Main Findings The research results show that in most cases, forcing exit - ramp vehicles to change lanes in advance through lane markings can significantly improve the operation efficiency. In particular, when the ramp flow proportion is relatively high, some specific lane - change management schemes (such as schemes 34 and 31) can effectively reduce the travel time of entrance - ramp vehicles without having a negative impact on main - line vehicles. ### Formula Representation The formulas involved in this paper mainly describe the rules of vehicle following behavior and lane - change behavior. For example: 1. **Maximum Possible Speed**: \[ v_{n}^{\text{max}}(t)=\begin{cases} v_n(t - 1)+1 & \text{if } v_n(t - 1)<V \text{ and } v_n(t - 1)<g_n(t)\\ v_n(t - 1) & \text{if } v_n(t - 1)=V \leq g_n(t)\\ g_n(t) & \text{if } g_n(t)\leq v_n(t - 1) \end{cases} \] 2. **Random Deceleration**: \[ v_n(t)=\begin{cases} v_n^{\text{max}}(t) & \text{if } \text{random}[0, 1]>p\\ v_n^{\text{max}}(t)-1 & \text{if } \text{random}[0, 1]\leq p \end{cases} \] 3. **Vehicle Position Update**: \[ x_n(t)=x_n(t - 1)+v_n(t) \] Through these formulas, the model can accurately simulate the behavior changes of vehicles under different conditions, thereby providing a scientific basis for the effectiveness evaluation of lane - change management strategies.