Comparison of the Unit Study and Traditional Approaches for Teaching Music Through School Band Performance

Robert J. Garofalo,Garwood Whaley
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/3344964
1979-10-01
Journal of Research in Music Education
Abstract:This study compared two approaches for teaching music concepts and skills through school band performance: (1) the Unit Study Composition and (2) the traditional rehearsal procedure. The comparison used two secondary school bands in a parallel-group design. Both bands rehearsed one work from a projected performance repertory. Students in each band were given an author-generated pre-, post, and post-posttest. After a five-week experimental period, the assessment data were collected from each group and subjected to standard statistical procedures. The support of each research hypothesis at a significant level indicated that students taught with the Unit Study Composition approach acquired conceptual knowledge, aural skills, and performance proficiency to a significantly greater degree than students taught with the traditional approach.
education & educational research
What problem does this paper attempt to address?