Thermal and Tidal Evolution of Ice Giants with Growing Frozen Cores: The Case of Neptune

David A. James,Lars Stixrude

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11214-024-01053-6

IF: 8.943

2024-02-21

Space Science Reviews

Abstract:The contrasting internal luminosity of Uranus and Neptune present a challenge to our understanding of the origin and evolution of these bodies, as well as extra-solar ice giants. The thermal evolution of Neptune is known to be nearly consistent with an entirely fluid interior, but this is not a unique solution, and does not account for the tidal dissipation required by the migration of its moons. We examine a model that has been previously shown to explain the thermal and tidal evolution of Uranus: one that features a growing, frozen core. The core traps heat in the interior, affecting the cooling time scale, and provides a source of tidal dissipation. We review the growing, frozen core model, and the computation of thermal and tidal evolution. We then apply this model to Neptune. We find that the growing frozen core model can account for the observed internal luminosity of Neptune and the migration of its moons, in the form of resonances that were either encountered or avoided in the past. We discuss prospects for observational tests of the growing frozen core model and possible implications for understanding the gas giants.

astronomy & astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the issues of thermodynamics and tidal evolution within Neptune and proposes a new model to explain the observed phenomena. Specifically, the paper attempts to address the following key questions:

1. **Explaining the internal brightness difference between Neptune and Uranus**: Despite Neptune and Uranus being similar in mass and radius, their internal brightness (i.e., the heat emitted from within) is significantly different. The paper aims to explain the reasons for this difference.

2. **Understanding the thermodynamic evolution of ice giants**: Traditional models suggest that Neptune's interior is almost entirely fluid, which can explain its internal brightness, but this model is not the only explanation and cannot account for the tidal dissipation required for changes in Neptune's satellite orbits. Therefore, the paper explores a new model that includes a continuously growing frozen core to better understand the thermodynamic evolution of ice giants.

3. **Explaining tidal dissipation and satellite migration**: The orbital changes of Neptune's satellites require a certain amount of tidal dissipation. By introducing a model with a continuously growing frozen core, the paper explains the phenomena of these satellite orbital changes, including situations where satellites encounter or avoid resonances.

4. **Validating the model's effectiveness**: The paper discusses how future observations can test the continuously growing frozen core model and explores the implications of this model for understanding gas giant planets.

In summary, this study aims to explain Neptune's thermodynamic and tidal evolution characteristics, particularly its significant differences from Uranus and the changes in Neptune's satellite orbits, through a new model that includes a continuously growing frozen core.