Abstract:In recent work by M.H.Lynch, E.Cohen, Y.Hadad and I.Kaminer (LCHK), a modified model of the Unruh-DeWitt quantum detector, coupled to a 4-vector current, has been proposed to examine the radiation emitted by high energy positrons channeled into silicon crystal samples. Inspired by their ideas, we analyze theoretical aspects of such a model, its internal consistency, and ignore all questions related to experiments. The two-potential correlation functions for the quantized electromagnetic field in a vacuum state and the corresponding detector radiation power (DRP), considered in proper time formalism, are used as the basis for investigating the radiation observed at an accelerating point detector. The quantum detector is assumed to be moving through an electromagnetic vacuum along a classical hyperbolic trajectory with a constant proper acceleration. The DRP is obtained for three possible cases. First, the DRP is found in a Lorentz-invariant manner. It contains both transverse and non-physical longitudinal polarization modes and is a divergent quantity. Second, the radiation power holds only physical transverse modes but it is non-relativistic and also depends on the detector proper time, which contradicts the fact that there is no preferred time for hyperbolic detector motion. Third, in the case considered by LCHK, for zero detector proper time when its velocity in the lab inertial system is zero, the radiation power with transverse modes shows some signs of thermality which could be associated with a detector acceleration but different from the Bose-Einstein statistics expected for the photon field. If the detector energy gap is zero then, in complete contradiction with what LCHK claim, there is no radiation and no "thermalized Larmor formula". Based on our analysis we do not believe that the LCHK's model can be used to support the idea about thermal effects of uniform acceleration.

Energy mechanism of charges analyzed in real current environment

On Nonpropagating Energy Around Antennas: Insights From the Theory of Radiation by Accelerated Charges

General description of electromagnetic radiation processes based on instantaneous charge acceleration in `endpoints'

Radiation pressure and the distribution of electromagnetic force in dielectric media (II)

Radiation reaction of classical hyperbolic oscillator: experimental signatures

Beyond Antenna Q: On Reactive Energy and the Need For a Spatio-Temporal Dynamical Paradigm

Theory of the interaction forces and the heat transfer between moving bodies mediated by the fluctuating electromagnetic field

Self-induced charge currents in electromagnetic materials, photon effective rest mass and some related topics

Dynamics under radiation damping from ab-initio formalism -nonlocal restraint on acceleration runaway in electrodynamics

Radiative acceleration and transient, radiation-induced electric fields

Spectral amplification and power absorption of charged particles under electric field and fluctuating magnetic field

Electromagnetic fields on a quantum scale. I

Radiation reaction and the acceleration-dependent mass increase of a charged sphere undergoing uniform acceleration

Some Theoretical Aspects of Observation of Acceleration Induced Thermality

Radiation Reaction fields for an accelerated dipole for scalar and electromagnetic radiation

Interpretations and naturalness in the radiation-reaction problem

Electrodynamics of accelerated charges or Why electron does not radiate in Rutherford's atom

Absorption of Electro-magnetic Waves in a Magnetized Medium

Space-time transformation properties of inter-charge forces and dipole radiation: Breakdown of the classical field concept in relativistic electrodynamics

Instantaneous and Retarded Interactions in Coherent Radiation

A local model for the optical energy and momentum transfer in dielectric media and the microscopic origin of Abraham's force density