Evaluation of the mindray CL900i CLIA HIV Ag/Ab combo assay for sensitive and specific HIV screening compared to established methods

Gheyath K. Nasrallah,Nadin Younes,Hadiya M. Khalid,Jawaher A. Al-Emadi,Salma Younes,Mazen Najib Abouassali,Manal Abdelmutaal Elshaikh,Ibrahim Wisam Karime,Mohammed Abdelfatah Ibrahim,Mutaz Mohamed Ali,Ibrahim Al Shaar,Na Liu,Houssein Ayoub,Hadi M. Yassine,Laith J. Abu-Raddad,Ahmed Ismail
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-024-78271-z
IF: 4.6
2024-11-24
Scientific Reports
Abstract:Architect-HIV Ag/Ab combo chemiluminescence assay is globally recognized for its sensitivity but has a notable false-positive rate. In this study, we aim to evaluate the performance of a new cost-effective screening alternative, the chemiluminescence Ag/Ab combo assay (CL-900i-HIV) from Mindray, China. We selected 195 archived samples categorized according to the INNO-LIATM HIV I/II, the gold standard confirmatory assay. These samples included true positive ( n = 38; positive by Architect-HIV & INNO-LIA-HIV), true negative ( n = 101; negative by Architect-HIV & INNO-LIA-HIV), false positive ( n = 20; positive by Architect-HIV & negative by INNO-LIA-HIV), and indeterminate results ( n = 26). We tested all samples using the Mindray CL-900i-HIV and all positive Architect-HIV samples ( n = 80) were confirmed by PCR. Compared to INNO-LIATM HIVI/II line immunoassay confirmatory assay, Mindray CL-900i-HIV demonstrated a sensitivity of 100% (95% CI 90.7–100), specificity of 100% (95% CI 97.0–100), overall percent agreement (OPA) of 100% (95% CI 97.7–100.0), and perfect agreement with the INNO-LIA confirmatory assay (κ = 1.00). Additionally, Mindray's CL-900i-HIV exhibited a significantly lower false-positive rate (8.75%) compared to Architect-HIV's (55%). Mindray CL900i demonstrated high sensitivity and very low false-positive rate, thus, has the potential to serve as an excellent, cost-effective surrogate for HIV screening, overcoming the limitations of existing automated assays.
multidisciplinary sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?