Implementation of a Prospective Index-Cluster Sampling Strategy for the Detection of Pre-Symptomatic Viral Respiratory Infection in Undergraduate Students

Diya M Uthappa,Micah T McClain,Bradly P Nicholson,Lawrence P Park,Ilya Zhbannikov,Sunil Suchindran,Monica Jimenez,Florica J Constantine,Marshall Nichols,Daphne C Jones,Lori L Hudson,L Brett Jaggers,Timothy Veldman,Thomas W Burke,Ephraim L Tsalik,Geoffrey S Ginsburg,Christopher W Woods
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/ofid/ofae081
2024-02-14
Open Forum Infectious Diseases
Abstract:Abstract Background and Objectives Index-cluster studies may help characterize the spread of communicable infections in the pre-symptomatic state. We describe a prospective index-cluster sampling strategy (ICSS) to detect pre-symptomatic respiratory viral illness and its implementation in a college population. Methods We enrolled an annual cohort of first-year undergraduates who completed daily electronic symptom diaries to identify index cases (ICs) with respiratory illness. Investigators then selected 5-10 potentially exposed, asymptomatic close contacts (CC) who were geographically co-located to follow for infections. Symptoms and nasopharyngeal samples were collected for 5 days. Logistic regression model-based predictions for proportions of self-reported illness were compared graphically for the whole cohort sampling group and the CC group. Results We enrolled 1379 participants between 2009-2015 including 288 ICs and 882 CCs. The median number of CCs per IC was 6 (IQR 3,8). Among the 882 CCs, 111 (13%) developed acute respiratory illnesses. Viral etiology testing in 246 ICs (85%) and 719 CCs (82%) identified a pathogen in 57% of ICs and 15% of CCs. Among those with detectable virus, rhinovirus was the most common (IC: 18%, CC: 6%) followed by coxsackie/echovirus (IC: 11%, CC: 4%). Among 106 CCs with a detected virus, only 18% had the same virus as their associated IC. Graphically, CCs didn’t have a higher frequency of self-reported illness relative to the whole cohort sampling group. Discussion Establishing clusters by geographic proximity did not enrich for cases of viral transmission, suggesting that ICSS may be a less effective strategy to detect spread of respiratory infection.
immunology,infectious diseases,microbiology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?