Is this advertisement designed to appeal to you? Adolescents' views about Instagram advertisements promoting ultra-processed products

Gastón Ares,Lucía Antúnez,Florencia Alcaire,Virginia Natero,Tobias Otterbring
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/s1368980024000533
2024-03-08
Public Health Nutrition
Abstract:Objective: Examine the key elements that characterize social media advertisements targeted at adolescents by asking adolescents which features of Instagram ads promoting ultra-processed products make them designed to appeal to adolescents. Design: Instagram ads promoting ultra-processed products and brands were selected from a database in which ads had been classified regarding whether they were primarily targeted at adolescents from an adult perspective. Adolescents completed a sorting task in small groups and were requested to reach a consensus through discussions and sticky notes regarding whether 60 ads were designed to appeal to them. The sorting task was analyzed using content analysis based on inductive coding. Setting: One private secondary school and two after-school clubs. Participants: Convenience sample of 105 Uruguayan adolescents aged 11 to 17 years. Results: Ten categories were identified regarding the reasons for sorting ads as (not) designed to appeal to adolescents: product type, graphic design, explicit references to age groups, language, activities or themes, memes, celebrities, characters, promotions, and novelty. Product type emerged as a key element, with adolescents perceiving ads as designed to appeal to them simply because they promoted specific products. Conclusions: This research contributes to the validation of criteria defined in previous studies and can be used for the development of tools to monitor the prevalence and power of adolescent-targeted digital marketing. However, the importance attributed to type of product suggests that regulations should not exclusively focus on exposure to digital marketing specifically targeted at adolescents but also on exposure to marketing in general.
public, environmental & occupational health,nutrition & dietetics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper aims to explore and identify adolescents' perceptions of ultra-processed food advertisements targeted at them on the social media platform Instagram and the key elements that attract them. Specifically, the study seeks to determine which features of Instagram ads make them appealing to adolescents by engaging them in a sorting task. The main objectives of the study include: - **Research Background**: Digital media has become an integral part of adolescents' daily lives, exposing them to marketing of ultra-processed products and fast-food restaurants across various platforms. Adolescents are highly sensitive to such marketing messages, despite having cognitive skills similar to adults. Evidence suggests that exposure to digital marketing of unhealthy foods and beverages is associated with increased recall, choice, and consumption of these products among adolescents. - **Research Purpose**: To identify, from the adolescents' perspective, which elements in Instagram ads promoting ultra-processed products are designed to be appealing to them. - **Research Methods**: A convenience sample of 105 Uruguayan adolescents (aged between 11 and 17) from different socioeconomic backgrounds was selected to complete a sorting task. They discussed and reached a consensus on whether 60 Instagram ads were designed to be appealing to them and recorded their reasons. - **Main Findings**: - The study identified ten reasons for classifying ads as (un)appealing to adolescents: product type, graphic design, explicit mention of age group, language, activities or themes, memes, celebrities, characters, promotions, and novelty. - Product type was identified as a key factor, with adolescents indicating that if an ad promotes a specific product, it suggests that the ad is designed to be appealing to them. - Other elements such as colorful designs, language, and activities associated with adolescents were also considered to enhance the appeal of the ads. - **Conclusion**: This study provides validation for the criteria defined in previous research and can be used to develop methods for monitoring the prevalence and impact of digital marketing targeted at adolescents. However, the importance of product type suggests that regulatory measures should not only focus on specific digital marketing targeting adolescents but also on general marketing exposure. In summary, the study reveals through direct adolescent participation how social media ads are designed to attract this group and emphasizes the need to consider broad product marketing in policy-making rather than limiting it to marketing targeted specifically at adolescents.